Is this sort of thing possible?

A word from our sponsor:

Printer-friendly version

Author: 

Blog About: 

I haven't been stopping in much lately, as I've spent much of the last several months binge-watching online movies and videos (an activity which, sadly, has taken the place of writing). Ironically, the movie I was watching last night might very well summon the writing muse again.

I happened to be up late, watching Regarding Henry on Hulu. For those who don't know, the movie is about a corporate lawyer who at least initially acts...well, the way you'd expect a stereotypical corporate lawyer to act. In other words, like an insufferable ass. He at the beginning of the movie had just succeeded in dismissing an elderly couple's lawsuit against a company clearly in the wrong, and gloats over his win. He can't communicate with his daughter, and his relationship with his wife is strained at best.

Then everything changes when he's s the victim of a convenience-store robbery.

Two bullets entered his brain, one doing devastating damage. He can no longer remember anything about his life. He cannot move or speak, and has the mind and emotions of a child.

As he recovers, he starts to look at his old life from a new perspective, and realizes it's a world in which he no longer fits. The accident turns out in a twisted way to be the best thing to happen to him, as it puts him on the path to being a new (and better) person.

That immediately put my mental gears in motion..

Of all the TG fiction stories I've read, I've never seen one in which amnesia plays a part. I've been mulling over such a storyline for years, but could never find the right "hook."

Years ago, I came up with a story idea in which a male-to-female transperson who has already transitioned gets into an accident, and remembers nothing before the moment she wakes up in the hospital. The family takes her home--or rather him. To the clearly unscrupulous and spiteful relatives, this is the perfect opportunity to force the protagonist to return to living as male, all the while insisting that's the way "he" always was. The protagonist, however, has a nagging feeling something is wrong, but can't pinpoint precisely what.

It would have been a story which examined the question of identity, but I didn't relish the idea of writing about such a despicable, unsupportive family.

Regarding Henry
, on the other hand, might have provided me with the hook I was looking for. Say a man (or even a young boy) with no previous indication of transgender behavior gets in an accident which causes brain damage, triggering impulsive behavior. Including the sudden desire to cross-dress.

My question to you all is, is this believable? One could, after all, make the argument that the desire was long suppressed, and the brain damage only released that desire by removing all the mental roadblocks. The more I think about it, the more fascinating it is to me.

It too could examine the question of identity, but in a far less cynical and mean-spirited way than the first idea. It's an idea, in short, that I could get really enthusiastic about.

Comments

I don't actually know...

If this could work or not in the real world, but I'd be happy to suspend my disbelief for a good story that has that as a main plot element.

Abigail Drew.

I saw a story like that

dawnfyre's picture

an accident takes the memory of a teen away ( 3 buddies dead in the accident ) and he remembers nothing, but very quickly realizes he should be a she.

it is here on BC, just don't remember the title or who wrote it.
if I remember right it stopped at a point it could, but really did want more to it.


Stupidity is a capital offense. A summary not indictable.

I think..

It is probably "Hop skip a jump in life" by Bailie Summers. The thing about that was she was already TG but had not yet told her family and slowly found her true feelings via a PTSD episode

I'm told STFU more times in a day than most people get told in a lifetime

historical precedence

Tanya Allan's picture

I recall reading Roberta Cowell's story - she was one of Britain's first 'sex change case' back in the 1950s. It is a fascinating story in its own right, and I recommend it to anyone. She was a Spitfire pilot in WW2 in the RAF, was shot down and was a POW at Stalag Luft 1 in Northern Germany, then became a racing driver after the war, to suddenly change gender. She claims to be XX and experienced menstruation, I read it aged just twelve and suddenly realised that I wasn't alone.
Anyway, my point - in the book, Roberta lists various other 'sex change' cases, and one was a soldier (French, I believe) who was blown up in the First World War. He was normal(?) man before, but afterwards had an irresistible urge to cross-dress and in fact be a woman. It's while since I read the story, so I'd recommend you find an on-line copy of her the autobiography and read it.

Tanya

There's no such thing as bad weather, just the wrong clothes!

Glad to see you're okay

Angharad's picture

I've used amnesia as a plot device in Bike on at least a couple of occasions, it can work either way or however twisted your imagination is (can't be worse than mine).

Angharad

Go for it!

I would certainly read it. as to any other stories with a similar plot (other than those already mentioned), there was one with a forced fem/identity death angle that was superbly written by the name of D.O.A. It really made me think on things. Good luck getting reacquainted with your muse

Amnesia vs. brain damage

Aljan Darkmoon's picture

I too have seen amnesia used successfully as a plot device in TG stories. However, the idea that my gender stuff could be the direct result of brain damage is not something I really want to contemplate, even though it would not surprise me should I happen to discover that my own messed-up life is the result of having been dropped on my head a few times too many. :|

Edit: given the above, could this possibly be a cause?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fpc5vgi9zbM