In response to a recent comment - the mature version

Printer-friendly version

Author: 

Blog About: 

Taxonomy upgrade extras: 

Ten years ago I wrote my very first story for Big Closet. The culture was different back then and the site was much, much smaller. It was a busy day if four stories got posted and Erin read each and everyone of them before posting (Congrats on not going crazy).

The story, How Life Can Change, created quit the stir way back then. I think it grew in popular because there wasn't really anything like it. At the time, there were only 5 stories dealing with transgendered kids (Erin named them in a blog) and none dealing with it on such a psychological level as I was. It grew quite the following and then a lot of bad things started happening in the story.

First off. I really didn't know what I was doing. I admit that. Second off, I was in a real bad place mentally at the time. I was going through a lot of pain of my own as I was dealing with the sexual abuse I suffered when I was young and I had just moved into the bedroom of one of the assailants.

But I used writing as a way to medicate and get things out on paper (or screen) and the horror and despair I was feeling transferred over, as well as the anger, the hate, and the ugliness. But instead of suffer because of the raw emotion I was feeling, the story prospered that I still have people asking about it today.

So, on to today's post.

I knew it was controversial. It was controversial back then and may be one of the most commented stories in BC history (52 individual comments). Back then comments didn't get pulled as they did today and there was quite the to do about what I wrote. That's why I blogged yesterday. But everyone encouraged me to post, so I did, hoping that the climate changed. In 10 hours I got one comment and it was not kind. I think the lack of comments said more to me, but the lone comment drove a nail in the coffin.

I am not a pedophile and I do not like being called one. I write mostly from my own experience and have gone through some stuff that I rather not have. It spilled over into my story and people didn't understand what was happening.

Here is the real story of why chapter 13 happened.

I was 8. I was living with my biological mother and Ritchie, her husband. Ritchie had a secret that he kept from the world, but not from me. Ritchie had a sexual attraction for young boys and I was readily available. The abuse I suffered did have a side effect, it made it for when I needed to excrete, I could not feel the need to go and would soil myself. One of the humiliations I suffered from soiling myself was being put in my sister's diapers. It was a horrible experience and probably the reason I can't connect with the adult baby/adult little girl scene though I've tried. I told my aunt about not feeling the need to go(I got a beating for that "what goes on in this house stays in this house") and she set an appointment for Dr. Leonard my pediatrician (cool how we had the same last name so it's easy to remember). So, on the day of the appointment, my mom is walking me there. All the way there she is telling me all the horrible things the doctor is going to do to me. He's going to shove huge metal rods as big as my arm in there to see what's wrong. He's going to cut me open to fix it, and other various forms of torture. By the time I got there, the condition set in and I had an accident and the doctor was unable to examine me. On the way home, my mom continued the horror stories. Stories about drills and big machines and just typing it I still get scared. I was magically able to feel the need to go even though the accidents continued and so did the peculiar punishment.

So today I get 1 comment on the story. The title calls me a pedophile and the body says EOM (which I guess stands for end of message). It bothers me for several reasons. First, the story is not pedophilia and actually is against it. Second, as a victim of such a crime I find the accusation particularly hurtful. Third, I am not the same person I was 10 years ago. I'm not even the same person I was six months ago.

I wanted to port this story over because people kept asking for it. I also wanted people to see how much I've grown in the craft. I see a lot of young, talented writers who might see that things do get better.

How Life Can Change was all over the place and very loose. I wrote a new version of it and called it A Different Kind of Life. It is the same premise, but you can see where I improved. But you take those two stories and look at Wrestling Against Myself and tell me if you can't tell the difference. Not only technical, but also with voice and mood. I am no longer that angry lost soul crying out for compassion. In my new stories there is a hope for the future that earlier pieces lacked.

I am going to take a step back and let my mind clear. I am in no shape to write on "Just Friends" and have learned that lesson the hard way many times before. I don't want to force something that isn't there.

Though my initial response was to take my pen and go home, I am only going on a short hiatus. There are still stories in me (lots and lots). And even a non fiction book with the premise that Transgender is not sin (an apologetic work to counter the christian right). I appreciate the support. Erin turned off comments to the story. I am going to make egg salad, come over if you want some.

Comments

Katie, I for one

have read your stories and appreciate your growth as an author.

    Stanman
May Your Light Forever Shine

On my way over.

As you said you wrote as a cathartic way of dealing with the pain. No apologies I would reason a lot of us do the same. And there is also the reason of comparison of your writing in an emotional state and a technical state. All stemming from an horrible experience as a child, but it helped you grow into the talented beautiful woman you are now. This is how we grow as humans this is how we deal, some use other unlawful methods you write. Keep on sharing your stories with us, I for one will keep reading. Love, Jenn.


I wear this crown of thorns
Upon my liar's chair
Full of broken thoughts
I cannot repair

ignore it

Sweetie,

People respond based upon past and present convictions, how their brain is wired, and situational awareness. Sometimes people can be crude simply because they can be. I do not read all the stories on this site ... I cannot. Some hurt me to the core. Some of the authors write the same genre every time. So there are some I never read. It does not mean they are not good authors, it means that what they write hurts because of my past, or scares me (the me who I am today).

In my mind, people who leave negative or angry comments tend to do so for petty reason or misinformed ones. Either way (to me) it shows a lack of compassion, and only hurts our family. If they are truly wanting to understand what the author is writing ... they would ask for clarification. Since they do not ... I would suggest you ignore what they say ... in the past I would have either responded with anger or internalize it. Do neither. Just ignore it. You are better than they are. Take the high road.

Kendra

Kendra Manderscheid

(One step at a time is working)

Ignore them

Leigh Veritas's picture

K.T. Don't give in, what you write is art. Yes sometimes it goes into the dark but to me that makes the light shine even brighter. I have read many of your stories, each is a unique and beautiful tale. Some have made me cry others have given me the resolve to go on. To me each story has a pearl of wisdom contained within. Each story contains a piece of your pain, joy, sorrow and yes happiness. Let not the nay sayers have there way. If Erin chooses this story to remain here, perhaps she sees the truth of the story or perhaps it is a allowance made for artistic expression. I support you and your writing. Thank you and please continue on if you feels right.

Courage is resistance to fear, mastery of fear - not absence of fear.
Mark Twain.

Leigh Veritas

I never have understood

Why people think they can just shoot from the hip every time something they don't like is written. Writing about a problem in our society doesn't make you guilty of the crime. I get so offended when someone is mean in a comment. I mean really, just pm me and I'll tell you what I think, but don't call an author out in public.
You have a right to be mad, girl.

Peace!
Cindilee

wow

KT I for one think you are a great writer I have brought some of your books. some ppl just have a small mind. if they don't know the whole story they shouldn't of said anything. so all I can say please keep up the good work because you and any body else that writes all these stories is what keeps me going. i'am a disable vet. and this is all I got.thank you

Complainers

DON'T LET THE NAYSAYERS WIN!

I have found in my life that those who become super offended and lash out do so because they are in denial. If you look at conservative gay-bashers I think many are using their bluster to tamp down the guilt they feel. Bashing is another form of bullying. The bully generally is in a dark place unable to make themselves feel better and worthwhile. Since they can't bring themselves up they use bullying in an attempt to pull others down to their level.

Don't let them win!

One of the reasons your stories are so great is because they come from your soul. Never let anyone else diminish your soul!

Keep on writing!

Jennifer Sue

Boys will be girls... if they're lucky!

Jennifer Sue

comments

Normaly I dont comment on stories because I figure not many care what a grouchy old retired veteran thinks anyway, but now I gotta say this....KT you are one of the most talented authors I have read in many years. how someone can take one of yours and try to find a perversion in it is beyond me, but If the idiot that does would like to meet with me to discuss this up close & personal ,just IM me & I will be there.I defend all of our rights to free speech & other things, but not the right to demean other by petty opinions. I have and will continue to defend these rights today, but ignorant & mean people also have the right to just keep it to theirselves. I am an angry... Papabru

small minds

Hi Katie,

Just remember, it's the people with small minds who have to shout the loudest.

Keep on, keeping on girl. We all love you.

Anesidora

I support Katie!

Its like I posted elsewhere, there are people who go off, Erin usually stomps on em pretty hard... I'm glad you're here and writing!

Abby

Battery.jpg

Don't let one closed minded

Amethyst's picture

Don't let one closed minded individual try to define you or your writing. They have no right to even try. If they had taken the time to actually read the entire work then they would have seen how much pain and suffering you must have gone through to have to write it. Raw emotions are hard on some readers but if a story isn't to their liking for that reason then they should stop reading it and move on to something that doesn't bother them rather than shooting the messenger in a public forum like that.

You have been through a lot and it's made you into a strong person and a fine writer. And anyone that doesn't see that needs to learn to not just see the words on the page but also to determine what the story means.

(hugs)

Amethyst

ChibiMaker1.jpg

Don't take me too seriously. I'm just kitten around. :3

I'll skip the egg salad....

Andrea Lena's picture

...one of my issues. But I do look forward to your new work; especially your apologetic. Thank you.

  

To be alive is to be vulnerable. Madeleine L'Engle
Love, Andrea Lena

You write about important subjects, Katie...

Ole Ulfson's picture

We discussed that sometime back. Important and adult!

Would that all who read them were adult enough to understand your writing and didn't imagine, mistakenly, that they were important...

I'm glad I don't know who it was or I'd probably fire off a PM that would burn the screen.

Well, except for one f*cking idiot it looks like the thinking population of this community support you'

I do!

Ole

We are each exactly as God made us. God does not make mistakes!

Gender rights are the new civil rights!

Some more support

K.T. - I just wanted to point out how much I love your work.

You shouldn't let one small-minded individual stop you from
expressing yourself through your writing; especially if that
writing is also very cathartic.

I know there are heaps of comments here saying the same thing,
but I just wanted to add my voice to those supporting you.
Enjoy the egg salad. :)

Dear K T

firstly i want to say that i love your writing, I read nearly all your Stories here.
Sometimes their are hard to read but it´s shows you write them with your Heart.
It´s a sad fact that some writers here need their storys to get over the abuse the suffert in their lifetime,
but it´s also helping others to see their are not alone in this suffering.
Don´t let one lone misguided person keep you away from something that is good.

I know i don´t comment enough, but often it is because other comments say already all i would want to say,
and i think my little scribble would be not be significant enough next to it.

Keep up with your wonderful work so that we have more fantastic stories to read.

Your Fan
SHH12

There will always be some.

Hypatia Littlewings's picture

There will always be some who dislike or disapprove just about anything, and some subjects are way more touchy then others.
It is no consolation, but it is a truism "You can't please everyone" etc.

Touching on or discussing or having a stories involving a topic does not mean condoning the action discussed. However there has developed such a knee jerk reaction to any thing regarding under aged in combination with sexuality that some will scream pedophile at the slightest mention of such topics even if you are condemning such action. And this with out paying any attention to what you may actually be saying or what your stance is on the subject.

There will always be stupid and unfeeling people or just those who are simply blinded by their own problems and point of view, don't let them get to you.

The only other thing I would say is, "Just make sure your stories have the proper warning tags on them so as not to surprise anyone"

Keep writing, your good at it.