SEE Commentaries #23 to #26

A word from our sponsor:

Printer-friendly version

Author: 

Blog About: 

Author's Commentary on Somewhere Else Entirely: Chapters 23 to 26

Garia gets back to business and then receives her first major test.

There isn't too much in these chapters that required major attention.

Chapter 23, Bells and Black Rock

Garia is still recovering from her unexpected bodily function but still manages to find out more interesting things.

Unfinished business

Throughout this tale there are a number of dangling threads, from ideas which I thought might bear investigation but which were either forgotten in the flow or turned out to be not such a good idea. One such is the discovery of "odd items" in the clear-out of what will become The Self Defense Training Room. I had an idea that maybe something from Earth might turn up, or maybe a weapon from some distant enemy that the locals didn't even recognize as a weapon - but Garia might.

In the event that didn't happen but there are still odd threads like that left through the story. I decided that these shouldn't cause the average reader too much difficulty. In a closely-plotted story most of these would be either eliminated or resolved. Real Life isn't like that, and I wanted to make this story reflect the vagaries of what really happens as life goes along.

Lady and Milady

I made a slight mistake here which I ended up repeating throughout the whole story. The correct title for a noblewoman of the lowest rank is Lady and she should always be referred to that way when being introduced. Milady is a contraction of My Lady and is usually used in direct address once the speaker has been formally introduced.

I am correcting these as I go through the chapters which means that some of the conversations will have a slightly different flavor. This should not detract from the overall tone of the story, though.

Coal

With regard to the Industrial Revolution, coal is such an important item that it had to be introduced early in the process. What I hadn't realized was just how central it would become to the whole story. At this point I hadn't even sketched out any journey to the north so the significance of coal at this point was very small.

Chapter 24, Back to Business

There are surprises for all as Garia appears wearing her new exercise gear. I had not especially decided that her tunic and skirt would be the colors of the guard but that turned out to be a useful plot point in this and subsequent chapters.

Bodily Contact

This is the first time Garia and Keren have been in physical contact since her period and the additional hormones, now in full flow, make an uncomfortable change to the way they interact. This is really the first time that the two discover a physical attraction for one another, even if it hasn't become emotional yet.

Chapter 25, Beastly Encounter

I had always intended this encounter and the following fight, but in practice it occurred a little sooner than I would have preferred. On the other hand, it fitted in nicely with everything else that was happening and produced a demonstration which fundamentally changes the relationship between Garia and the Palace. Up until this point she has just been a stranger full of ideas but after the fight she really becomes one of the Royal Family, even if only adopted.

The Korond Gown

This is the gown 'lent' to Garia when she first arrives in the city. She wears it again here and then all mention of it goes quiet. This is another of those loose ends mentioned above. I do believe that it is subsequently described as being cleaned and then returned. There is no real significance in what happens to it, save that it caused a loose end.

Korond himself was only intended to be a casual mention in chapter 3. I was surprised and gratified to discover, much later, that his establishment would receive another visit, for very different reasons.

Chapter 26, A Matter of Honor

I had to choreograph two fights here, the first a verbal one at the breakfast table and then the physical one in the Large Training Room. The first was actually harder here because it was necessary to maneuvre everybody around to the consequence I wanted, which was that Jarwin would somehow throw down a challenge to Garia, thus giving her the choice of weapons.

Jarwin uses the word cow here, and one or two readers have questioned it. However, milk appears to be available in Palarand and therefore at least one kind of mammal must produce it. I have carefully not explained the exact details of the origin of local milk but I think the use of the word cow is permissible.

I had forgotten, even while writing this chapter, that in this society no man would ever challenge a woman, and so it was also necessary to twist things in order to get the right result. Fortunately for me and for the story, Jarwin did all that I asked of him.

The physical fight went off more or less as expected. I did have some trouble figuring out Garia's and Jarwin's lefts and rights and I have made some tiny adjustments here. Otherwise I think things resolved themselves as expected. Garia is no Mary Sue, she suffers injuries like any other 15 year-old Anmarian girl would.

Comments

"cow"

Well the way Jarwin used the word, it was as an insult, so the auto-translate converted it to the nearest equivalent insult, after all when we deliver insults, the meaning of our words generally becomes more basic, then the actual definition of the words themselves, so the use is definitely permissible

You do know that...

You do know that your commentaries also act as enticement to re-read SEE.

I think this will be about the 6th time around.

On usage of "COW" as an insult, how strong the insult is depends on where it's used. In this case, Garia needs to use her judgement.

Odd items

I figured the odd items comment referenced the sword set for ladies that served as a template for Garia's short sword set.

As much of an ass as Jarwin was it didn't surprise me that she could goad him into doing what she wanted him to do. And Garia jumping in to protect Meri was totally in character. Granted, Robanar apparently had the situation in hand, but Garia didn't know this. She was still reflecting the conditioning of growing up in the United States where powerful people just didn't concern themselves with the little "guy". She just hasn't been in Anmar long enough to take onboard the differences between the medieval times on Earth and the superficially similar situation she finds herself in.

And lets face it, the king is different even among the local royalty. He isn't afraid to get his hands dirty if need be and his concern for those he rules over is out of the ordinary. This is what makes him a great king and his son has learned from the best. That's part of what attracts Garia to Keran. Keran walks the walk even more than he talks the talk. Loyalty is earned and both the king and his son have earned it in full measure.


"Life is not measured by the breaths you take, but by the moments that take your breath away.”
George Carlin

A suggestion?

First, I have to assume people reading this far into the comments here have read SEE in its entirety; if not let this serve as a warning that I am discussing elements that come up later openly!

If you wanted to make use of the items found in the training room... perhaps it's not such a stretch for the gun to be found among those items rather than in the laboratory? It actually struck me as odd that Garia would not have noticed it with how much time she spent in there.

Ever been in a cluttered basement

BarbieLee's picture

I will expand on that. How about an old storage room? An old work shop? An old laboratory? Maybe you can relate to attic storage?
Things get placed, pushed back, hidden, covered, lost. Until virtually every box, cover, item is pulled out things will remain hidden, forgotten. A man went back to his father's house and started pulling things out of the attic hidden away before WII no one knew was there.
Remember Garia never finished cleaning the lab.
always,
Barb

Oklahoma born and raised cowgirl

Old stuff stored away

I agree with Barb. There are a couple of points I could make here.

The first is that items in the training room are either "old stuff" previously in use by the Palace Guard or things obtained after battle or conquest; war booty if you will. It is unlikely that an Earth firearm would be collected as a result of a local conflict. That would imply that an Earth transferee had such a weapon, with ammunition, and used it and lost it during a battle in previous times.

It is much more likely that such a weapon would be found along with the transferee when they were first discovered. In that case, whether they retained the weapon or not; whether it was ever fired or not, it would likely end up with the Royal Questor as a curiosity in due course. Now imagine that happened 100 years previously, with the 'strange metal device' stored away with all the other weird stuff that turns up from time to time.

Secondly, all the stuff in the training room has been sorted and bagged and stored away tidily. Garia is too busy when she is in there to spend time going round and looking at everything, despite what was first suggested. It is D'Kenik who notices and recognizes the twin swords. He may have first seen them when the room was being cleaned out, but of course he would have kept his mouth shut at that point.

In fact, Garia hasn't time to go through the laboratory either. In the time she does spend in the lab she finds the Antikythera device but that's all. It is left to Sigsten to discover the two pistols based on rough descriptions that Garia gives him.

I have to admit here that Sigsten finding two pistols at the precise point that examples of such weapons are required is a bit pat, really. I may do something to soften the 'coincidence' when I get around to those chapters.

Penny

PS, Oh, yeah, I have a garage just like that. One day...

Garage analogy

Well, these kinds of heirlooms may possibly pass on through the transferee's heirs. Who knows whether there are such stashes elsewhere, whatever forms it takes. Maybe they should have a 'bring your mystery trinket/thingabob to the Palace' day or something.

Firearms

If it wasn't for the issue of priming the guns, I would be surprised that they went for lever action as opposed to manual load bolt action for the rifles, after all while lever action is faster to reload (at least when standing) it forces a laying down rifleman to at least reposition the rifle, mind you with black powder smoke, they shouldn't stay anywhere too long once they are facing other snipers,

I will admit

That upon my first read I thought that Garia would have spent some time looking at equipment found in the training room, but even so, it did serve 2 purposes, first it shows that the captains value her input and second when the sword set that was used as a template does show up, it isn't completely out of place, as for the pistols, well considering that the first significant item found in the lab was the oldest known mechanical computer, it shows that the last several royal questors had a tendency to try to figure out the mechanical mystery objects more so than the rest, meaning that those objects would be the easiest to access, and without knowing the chemical component to the devices, let alone their purpose (though they might have infered some based on similarities to a crossbow) the guns seem to be almost purely mechanical devices,