Jenni's Dilemma

Printer-friendly version
Jenni's Dilemma

 

By Roxanne Michelle Roseberry

 
Jenni has something to tell her mother, but she's scared of how she'll react. Can she find the courage to tell her or will she need her twin sister Jessica's help?


Author's note: This would ideally have accompanying images and be a children's story, but alas I don't really have the time or skill to bring those images to life myself. This story is copyright © to me, please so do not reproduce or distribute without my consent.


 
Jenni was very scared as she walked into the kitchen to talk to her mother. Her sister Jessica wanted to come with her. They were twins and did nearly everything together, but this was something that she needed to do on her own.

She was eight years old and she knew that she was different than her sister, but she couldn’t understand why. They looked very similar and many people could only tell them apart from the boy clothes that Jenni usually had to wear but she had something that her sister did not. Her parents had told her once that this was because she was a boy like her big brother Peter.

Jenni did not feel like a boy. She knew deep down that she was a girl. She did not like the clothes that she had to wear or playing with her brother and the neighborhood boys. Some of the sports were okay, but she would much rather spend time with Jessica and her friends. Their games were better and she would sometimes get to play dress-up with her sister’s clothes. She liked when they played dress-up, she did not feel like she had to pretend to be a boy, she could be herself.

She wanted to feel like that all the time. But her parents had explained the differences between boys and girls and that her body was that of a boy. They used some big words that she did not really understand, but they seemed sure. But that was on the outside. She wondered if there was something inside her that was different, something that made her a girl.

She was afraid to speak and she just wanted her mother to tell her stories like she usually did when one of her children was upset. She would always start with the words, “You are a legend, for your deeds have been great and the tales of your heroism are many.” Then she would tell stories about things they had done, making it sound like a big adventure. Jenni wanted that now, but she feared that her mother would be angry instead.

She thought about all of these things as she watched her mother cleaning the dishes. Then she tugged nervously at the dress that she wore, that she had borrowed from her sister. It was not the dress that made her uncomfortable. No, it made her feel more confident, it made her feel like herself. She was scared about what her mother would say.

“Momma,” she spoke in a scared voice. To tell the truth, it sounded more like a squeak than a speak.

“Yes, Jessica?” her mother asked as she turned around. For a moment she gave Jenni a long and strange look. Then she asked, “James, why are you wearing your sister’s clothes?”

“Momma,” she declared as she tried very hard not to cry, “I am wearing girl clothes because I am a girl.”

Jenni’s mother sighed and looked thoughtfully at her child. Ever since Jenni had first asked why she could not dress like her sister and the other girls she had been doing a lot of reading, and thinking, and talking with Jenni’s father about it. She had discovered that sometimes people who are girls inside may look like boys on the outside and that some boys may be born looking like girls. There were even ways to make those children match who they were inside on the outside, though it would take time and patience.

“I have never heard of a girl named James,” Jenni’s mother said thoughtfully. Jenni was afraid that she was going to tell her to put her yucky boy clothes back on and could feel herself starting to cry until her mother spoke again. “You can’t be James then, so what is your name?”

“J-j-jenni,” her child stammered, tears falling down her face.

Jenni’s mother scooped her up in her arms and sat at the kitchen table, holding her and rocking her in her arms. “Shhhh, don’t cry. There is nothing to cry about or fear because you are Jennifer. You are a legend, your deeds have been great and the tales of your heroism are many.”

“I remember the time that you and Jessica battled alongside your father to bake me a birthday cake. The battle in the kitchen spread far and wide and the destruction was great, but the three of you emerged victorious with a chocolate cake with pink frosting. The cleanup afterward was long and difficult, but not once did you or Jessica complain. You fought fiercely against the dirty dishes and made your parents proud that day,” Jenni’s mother told her as she wiped tears away.

Jenni looked up and her mother smiled down at her as she gently told her, “You are my child. I do not love you for the body you were born in, I love you for who you are inside. If that is Jennifer instead of James then all that matters to me is that you are happy.”

Jessica ran into the kitchen from where she had been listening and hugged her mother and her twin. She knew that Jenni could do it. And if she could not do it alone then Jessica would have been there with her. She was worried though and she could tell that her sister was too so she asked. “Momma? What about Daddy and Peter and all of the other people that think Jenni is a boy?”

The girls’ mother put her arms around both of her daughters. “The journey might be dangerous and the battles great, but we will face them together. We will be victorious together too, and do you girls know why?”

“Why Momma?” The pair of girls asked as Jenni was still sniffling and crying. They were not tears of fear though, these were tears of happiness.

Their mother merely smiled and said, “Jessica, you stood ready to wage battle in your sister’s name when she was frightened to tell me who she really was. There is no greater sister or friend in all the land.” Jessica beamed proudly as she nodded.

She turned then to Jenni and added, “Jennifer, you were afraid the whole time, but still you found the courage to declare to me that you know who you are inside, even if the whole world may think differently. That courage will see you through whatever you face.” She softly brushed Jenni's hair with her fingers as Jenni sniffled, bit her lip, and tried to smile for her mother.

Their mother kissed both girls on the forehead and then spoke again with a smile that showed the love she had for both of her daughters. “And I once carried two baby girls in my belly for nine whole months. Then I fought the Beast of Labor for seventeen hours to bring them safely into this world. We can do anything together because we are legends. Our deeds have been great and the tales of our heroism are many.”

up
158 users have voted.
If you liked this post, you can leave a comment and/or a kudos! Click the "Thumbs Up!" button above to leave a Kudos

Comments

Wonderful!

Love conquers all, Nice! Loving Hugs Talia

Thanks Talia

Both for giving it a read before posting and helping with a title.

*big hugs*

Roxanne (AKA Amethyst)

Jenni and her mother...

are both courageous: Jenni for continuing her stand and her Mom's courage to change. I hope to see you writing more.

Hugs, Jessie C

Jessica E. Connors

Jessica Connors

Thanks Jessie C

I do write more, I just decided that since this was such a break from my regular writing, in both style and content, to use a nom de plume. I have posted other things on BCTS under my own name, Amethyst. I'm hoping to write more children's stories like this but I felt that for professional reasons I should keep them separate from my usual stories which are written for a higher reading level and sometimes contain more adult content.

*big hugs*

Roxanne (AKA Amethyst)

Great!

Glenda98's picture

Great little story!

Glenda Ericsson

I'm glad you liked it

It's quite a bit different from what I usually write, so I'm glad that it turned out so well.

*big hugs*

Roxanne (AKA Amethyst)

Just picture two seven or

Just picture two seven or eight year-old kids in the kitchen trying to bake a cake, the description is fairly accurate. I know this from experience lol.

I'm hoping to do more stories like this for a younger audience since it didn't take long to write. We'll see how fast the ideas come though.

*big hugs*

Roxanne (AKA Amethyst)

Unconditional

Andrea Lena's picture

“You are my child. I do not love you for the body you were born in, I love you for who you are inside. If that is Jennifer instead of James then all that matters to me is that you are happy..."

Every one of us so desperately needs this kind of love. Brava!

  

To be alive is to be vulnerable. Madeleine L'Engle
Love, Andrea Lena

Thank you Drea

My own mom has actually been really accepting of my transition. That's why for children's books like this I took the nom de plume from the name she had picked for me before I was born and her maiden name. She never really had any boy names picked out for me because she was certain I was a girl. Seems she was right all along even if biology threw me a temporary curve ball.

*big hugs*

Roxanne (AKA Amethyst)

A Nice Tactic

Daphne Xu's picture

That's a nice tactic to use to tell children about things that have happened, and about somewhat adult things.

-- Daphne Xu

Thanks Daphne

This story was actually based on a dream I had where I was the mother. Even though I felt bad for what I knew Jenni was going to go through I kind of didn't want to wake up from the dream. When I woke up I was like, OMG I have to write all that down it's such a brilliant way to teach lessons to children or to comfort them, after all we're all the heroes in our own stories.

*big hugs*

Roxanne (AKA Amethyst)

Momma Is Great

joannebarbarella's picture

She is a legend, her deeds have been great and the tales of her heroism are many. Would all mothers would be like her.

That's the kind of mother

that I've always wanted to be myself. I really didn't want to wake up from the dream that inspired this.

*big hugs*

Roxanne (AKA Amethyst)

The underlying sadness of the story is...

Rhayna Tera's picture

“Momma? What about Daddy and Peter and all of the other people that think Jenni is a boy?” The girls’ mother put her arms around both of her daughters. “The journey might be dangerous and the battles great, but we will face them together. ..."

Outsiders are one thing. But dad and big brother might pose a danger to her on her journey? That's saddening.

Sadly

Such is the world we live in, but it is starting to get better in some ways. Momma did her research after the first sign that Jenni thought she was a girl and talked to Jenni's father it seems, so maybe he'll be prepared for it even if he can't really accept it at first. From there they can hopefully teach Peter that he has two sisters as well.

*big hugs*

Roxanne (AKA Amethyst)

"we are legends."

and so is the author of this story!

glad you found a title, hon. if your muse agrees I wouldn't mind seeing more of this one

DogSig.png

Aww thanks Dot

We'll have to see where things go with this writing of children's stories. I could see a series of stories based around Jenni and her transition, with more legendary stories about her life contained within, but I may have other stories along this vein to tell as well. I'd need a proper illustrator to work with before I could officially publish any of them though.

*big hugs*

Roxanne (AKA Amethyst)

Cute

Alice-s's picture

I liked it. Very sweet.

Thanks Alice

I'm glad that you liked it. It was a nice dream, I thought it should be shared, and it leaned toward a children's story. I don't get to do those much, if ever.

*big hugs*

Roxanne (AKA Amethyst)

Where's my tissues?

Didn't see the tearjerker alert. Very sweet. Loved the images the words formed in my head. No graphics were needed.

>>> Kay

I teared up after the dream

I teared up after the dream this was based on and while writing it too. I really should have thought to put a tissue-alert on it but I wasn't really sure if it would touch people the way it touched me. I had those feelings from the dream, but I couldn't be sure that it would translate well to others because it felt like I should do it as a children's story but I haven't really done much of that kind of writing.

*big hugs*

Roxanne (Amethyst)