Summer Romance 2009 Contest Winners

A word from our sponsor:

Printer-friendly version

Author: 


TopShelf's
 Summer Romance 2009 
Story Contest Winners

Hello Everyone,

I apologize for what marred my otherwise beautifully run Summer Romance Contest for 2009. Lessons have been learned and we will improve. Because of what happened, I looked at snapshots of the totals daily for everyone since day 1 for voting and found 4 stories led the entire pack during each day. Since 2nd and 3rd place cannot rightfully be determined because of this incident, I decided to up the prize amount so that each of the four top winners will receive $40 each. That is the only fair way I can see for awarding the prize money.

Secondly, Everyone who entered, was a winner! I mean that. I wish I could afford to reward everyone who did write for the contest because I feel they all deserve something for their time and effort.

Thirdly, the winners are, in no particular order: Saless My Summer Mutation, AshleyTS Ashley's Magical Summer, Jesse Rabbit A Man Among Vikings, and Melanie Ezell (Rasufelle) Dear John. If each of you would PM me with your contact information and please let me know how you would like your prize money delivered (Money order or Paypal), I will distribute the prize monies this week.

Fourthly, I run these contests to spur creativity, not popularity. I mentioned this last night on the voting page, but it no longer exists.

Lastly....

The next contest that I will host is The TG Terror Contest in October. I will post the rules in September as this contest will be much shorter than the Summer Romance one in order to fit within the month.

Sephrena Lynn Miller
BigCloset TopShelf
TGLibrary.com

 
 
 
 
Pictures provided by:
Rose - free usage license at www.batkhela.com
Butterfly - free usage license at www.free-nature-animal-butterfly-wallpaper.com
anime: unknown.

Comments

My favourite didn't win a prize

but it did win a heart - mine. BUT - all the stories were winners, as were all of us readers.

Thank you to all the authors and the organisers.

Susie

I have mixed feelings about this...

On the one hand, I'm ecstatic at how well my story did! On the other, I feel like I'm benefiting from this in that I'm sure my story was going to be fourth, at best. So my story wouldn't even be listed on this page if someone hadn't messed with the voting. Arggh!

Still, it was a great contest, with a lot of wonderful stories! We all won in this regardless of how many votes each story received. Thanks Sephrena for setting this contest up! I'm sorry it didn't go as smoothly as you planned, but it was still great!

Saless

P.S. Thanks to everyone who voted for my story! ^_^
 


"But it is also tradition that times *must* and always do change, my friend." - Eddie Murphy, Coming To America


"But it is also tradition that times *must* and always do change, my friend." - Eddie Murphy, Coming To America

Sephrena, I do have to agree

Sephrena, I do have to agree with Susan's comment that altho certain stories did win, I beleive all the authors are winners and due to their creativity, they make us all the better as both readers and fans. Kudos to all of them and their talents. Janice Lynn

Back To The Drawing Board

joannebarbarella's picture

Of course I knew I would never win, having read the competing stories even before voting began. Congratulations to the winners, all fine stories. Of those, I confess that none of them was my actual favourite.

I was torn between "Frends Forever" and "The Waitress", both of which I thought embodied the purpose of the competition, i.e. Romance, in the best possible way.

That's my opinion, not meant to detract from the popularity of the four winning stories. The main thing was that every author produced something that the audience liked and there was a wide range of subject material to satisfy all tastes. It was fun and I suggest it should be an annual event.

As to the voting, my memory says that last year it was a kind of secret ballot and there was no way of knowing how a story was doing until voting was complete. Am I correct? While that wouldn't necessarily stop vote-stacking it would make it harder (although it's frustrating being in the dark).

Alternatively, why not just take the votes garnered by each story when it appears and have a cut-off date say one week after the posting. Most stories get voted on in the first few days after they appear anyway and with the forty day bar on voting a second time multiple voting could only be done through a second account, but the effect would be greatly reduced.

For instance, if the two top stories had, say, 100 votes and 90 votes there would have to be at least six irregularities (assuming they were done by authors) to change the result and they would have to be committed within the first week of publication.

Would that work or some derivative of it?

Finally I most gratefully thank those kind people who voted for my story. I ended up being in some very flattering company and I am well satisfied with that,
Joanne
No it's not. You silly cow.
Barbarella

The server software updates monthly

so the same voting module we used back then doesnt work now. Erin has to custom code from module samples for the newer version of drupal as it constantly updates. That is why she has such a headache to keep the few custom modules she has for BCTS running. She and Bob has to program those themselves.

This site takes a lot of work to run it, and those two do mainly the software and hardware end of it.

Never doubt that the next contest will be more secure. The module will be a headache to fix but it will be secret ballot and we will be checking things like ip adds and such to eliminate multiple account cheating. Turning off creating accounts could be a possibility during the contest. The point is we will do all that is feasibly possible to keep it fair.

I don't like cheaters. And we have software to track down the cheaters.

It takes effort to perform and show off talent. That is what I strive to bring out of each and every one of you, whether you are a writer or reader or both.

BigCloset TopShelf is about talent and the spirit of fairness and enjoying the uniqueness of each other's works.
 
 
Sephrena Lynn Miller
BigCloset TopShelf
TGLibrary.com

Turning off creating accounts

That might be a little too hard for new readers, because it could potentially put them off the site permanently.

I have a small variation on that, which might be even be easier to implement. Allow accounts to be created as usual. In the voting logic, disallow people from voting (but nothing else) who create accounts after the voting is opened. Our accounts have create dates/times, yes? A simple test ought to cover this one.

* Of course, this doesn't prevent people from pre-creating accounts before voting starts to get round this or any similar rule. Other than checking IPs, I can't think of anything else to try. Even "voting cookies" can easily be gamed.

Oh, well, back to the drawing board.

Penny

It wasn't bad :D

Honestly, things could have been a lot worse. As for the recommended alternative voting methods for the next contest: they all have advantages, too. In truth, I think the only problem with the voting mechanism used is that, since the software used to run the site is forum software, it is built with forum standards in mind, so the voting software is designed for more of a polling-type situation than a contest-voting one. There's probably an option somewhere in the software that would offer a hidden voting mechanism, but then again I'm not a Drupal expert (nor am I even mildly conversant in it) so I'm probably talking out my rear.

Things could have been a lot worse - I'm just glad they were caught when they were. I'm sure that next contest, everything will be fine :P

Melanie E.

Congratulations!

terrynaut's picture

Yeah. My favorites got an award. I'm most pleased. Yes yes. Most pleased. :)

Thanks very much for the stories.

Hugs for everyone

- Terry

Computer Chads - Is John McCain really the President?

RAMI

I am scared, very scared!

I am a resident of the Great State of Florida, home to all kind of Chads. If voting by computer, in a simple situation as this (that is not meant to demean, the contest, the stories or the effort of the administrators - they were all Great!!) can lead to voter fraud and manipulation what can happen in real life political races. A great percent of votes in 2008 were done by computer voting. Was John McCain actually elected President :-)?

RAMI

RAMI