Art and Text (part 1)

A word from our sponsor:

Printer-friendly version

Author: 

Blog About: 

Flip

When I first started writing TG fiction, I had in mind a collection of illustrated stories similar to the image posted above. Unfortunately, digital formats such as kindle don't handle wrap-around text very well (I've tried all of the kindle variants, including the Textbook Creator, the Comic Book Maker etc), so I've generally gone with PDF format when publishing my own material. Needless to say, PDF also has its drawbacks in terms of text flow and zoom functions; in the present day there seems to be no happy medium unless you're willing start your own website and to do some major tinkering with HTML.

Naturally, a piece of fiction should be able to stand on its own merits, but as pointed out elsewhere, TG literature has a long history of illustrated storylines, in which the images are intended to compliment the narrative. Speaking for myself, I was always intrigued by the idea of producing magazine-style digital publications; as far back as the early 90s, I was taking courses in Photoshop and Quark Xpress to explore the possibilities.

Certainly, in the Age of Amazon, we're all aware of how important an eye-catching cover is to a book's potential sales, but how about the interior? Do you consider illustrations to be an unnecessary distraction from the textual content, or could a few well-placed images actually enhance the overall reading experience?

Comments

Images and flow and publishing and the rest

crash's picture

I like stories that have illustrations. I like illustrations that tell a story. I like stories that paint pictures with words. I also like stories that have illustrations of the pictures that the words paint. I like comic strips. I like manga and anime.

But at the bottom of it all I like good work by talented authors, graphic designers, illustrators and artists. It's rare to find one person who can do it all of that.

Your friend
Crash

Dodgson

crash's picture

Though Dodgson appears to have been a bit of a creep. Alice is one of my literary heroes. Right up there with Lucy Pevensie, John Carter, and R. Daneel Olivaw.

Your friend
Crash

As I recall...

Daphne Xu's picture

As I recall, he had a nice relationship with the live version of Alice.

-- Daphne Xu

I'm Not Visual...

...not sure why. Don't watch television except local sports events, and I'm more likely to catch those on radio than the tube when that's possible. Haven't been to a movie theater in years; I think "Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade" with Sean Connery was the last non-documentary I saw, and that was because I got a gift card for that theater chain as a holiday gift.

Anyway, illustrations in stories don't matter to me. On relatively rare occasions, they can even be a nuisance, when authors try to bend their character descriptions around pre-existing pictures that don't really seem to fit, or when the young person in the picture looks a lot older or younger to me than the one in the story. Or when there are elements to the character's appearance -- tattoos, multiple piercings, grotesqueries of various kinds -- that are part of the story but they're things that I'd rather overlook or at least not have pushed in my face, so to speak.

That said, I'm pretty sure I'm in the minority on all this, very possibly extremely so.

Eric

For the most part ...

... I like seeing pictures in stories. There are times, though, when a picture can take away from a story rather than add to it. For instance, a picture at the beginning of a story might set up an expectation that not met in the text. A picture in the middle or at the end of a story could conflict with the mental image you've already built up by what you've read. There may be other issues that come up too. I haven't seen these issues come up very often in stories I've read, but it might be something to keep in mind.

Pictures in ebooks remain tricky

bryony marsh's picture

I did a (non-TG) book with illustrations in the print paperback, but doing the same with the Kindle ebook was nothing but hassle for the reasons you mention – so I just did the ebook without pictures.

Apple’s iBooks format handles images and formatting well (plus interactive elements, if that’s your thing...) but then you’re limited to an Apple-only audience, which has always seemed kind of pointless to me. For now, I’m aware of no ideal solution. It would be a nice option to have, though.

Happy memories of Quark Xpress!

B.

Sugar and Spiiice – TG Fiction by Bryony Marsh