Deep Cover
Prologue
Harkness Holdings had just posted another astounding quarterly earnings statement that left Wall Street analysts breathless with excitement. The chattering financial commentators were agog. Forbes, Fortune, The Wall Street Journal were all touting the quarter-by-quarter meteoric rise of Beauregard “Beau” Chadsworth, Harkness’ CEO, and his team who’d taken the moribund company and pushed it to the heights of Wall Street stardom. Harkness’ share prices reflected the unbounded confidence of investors big and small. From the get-rich-quick types to the most cautious investors, Harness was what they all wanted.
“Beau,” for Beauregard, Chadsworth was the darling of the talk show hosts who outdid one another in their fawning praise. In the post-Enron scandal era, Harkness was basking in its squeaky clean image. And Chadsworth, for his part was all becoming modesty. He was quick to point to the success and support of his team, Jack Levin the COO and Bridget O’Leary the CFO and their subordinates. Then there was the Chadsworth Foundation, already being talked about in the same breath as Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, so recently bolstered by the largess of Warren Buffett.
All was golden in the second and third quarters of 2006. Or so it seemed.
Chapter I
To the casual observer, the scene was ordinary, six friends enjoying a wine and cheese picnic on the white sands of one of those idyllic hamlets along North Carolina’s Outer Banks. They were all dressed for it, too. The women in bright, stylish cover-ups, the men either bare-chested or like Bob Wynant pulling a seersucker hoodie on to ward off the late summer evening’s oncoming chill. The three couples looked to all the world as if they were enjoying a well earned vacation respite from their busy lives.
It was all a sham. Camouflage, really. Tony Jackson, that’s Anthony Hope-Jackson to be precise, was the reason for the charade. You see, Tony was the one person who knew what really went on at Harkness Holdings. He wasn’t exactly a whistle blower, well, at least not yet. Let’s just say the slightly greying, but otherwise fit and trim forty-year old had discovered, that Harkness’ books weren’t exactly “cooked,” but, as he liked to say, “microwaved.” On a doubly encrypted laptop, he had documented schemes within schemes at Harkness to hide massive losses, to shield assets from the prying eyes of Harkness’ accountants, the IRS and the SEC. In a word, a corporate shell game of such breathtaking proportions, that third-world, and even first-world economies would be shaken if it were to be revealed.
What to do. Enter the Fraud Units from the New York State Attorney General’s Office, their counterparts from the State of Delaware, technically the “home” of Harkness and the otherwise somnolent Washington bureaucracies of the FBI and the SEC. Tony Jackson’s problem was how to play the extraordinary hand he had been dealt. If too much of what he knew were to be revealed, all fingers would point to him. Who else knew so much? The various investigators knew that even though Jackson had left Harkness only a few months before, and on the friendliest of terms, the tangled web that was Harkness was becoming more labyrinthine by the moment. The fine line between sharp business practice and outright criminality had been crossed long ago. Tony Jackson was one of the very few people outside Harkness’ inner circle who knew the full extent of the frauds that were being perpetrated.
Tony Jackson, himself beginning to feel the chill, buttoned his faded Hawaiian shirt before leaning back on his elbows, his gaze fixed firmly on the horizon. His “date,” in reality attorney Barbara Morrison, Bob Wynanat and his “wife,” FBI agent Ruth Rabinowitz, were joined by Tara and Bill McKay, of the Delaware AG’s office. Six friends enjoying the fading light of dusk to the accompaniment of the soft splash of the outgoing tide. They faced the water for another reason as well: microphones. Chadsworth had feted Tony on his “retirement” from Harkness to be sure, but Harkness’ high-stakes game made that inner cohort so suspicious that they were not above sending teams to make sure their “friends” were not straying from the fold.
“Tony,” Wynant began, almost in a monotone, “it can work, it should work, it must work. Your family and Chadsworth’s go way back. You yourself told me that at one time he dated your cousin, Amanda. He’s never allowed any woman in his life to get as close to him as she got, not his former wife, not any of his girlfriends. It’s also no secret that you and she look more like twins than cousins. You’ve said so yourself. She’s fine with the idea. You’re the last remaining hurdle.”
As far as Tony was concerned, what Bob Wynant was suggesting was patently absurd. The fact that everybody else on that beach blanket wasn’t contradicting Wynant made him that much more uneasy. “What you’re saying, Bob, is I should just throw on a dress and go marching into Harkness’ headquarters and demand a job?”
“Not really, Tony,” Bob added, soothingly. “What we want you to do is spend some time with Amanda. Up until a couple of years ago, you used to vacation together, for heaven’s sake. Nothing unusual in that. Take a cruise. Rent a villa in Tuscany for a month. Whatever. And at the end of it, you reemerge as Amanda and Tony — Amanda in male drag — goes trekking in the Himalayas for a while,...something like that. You, as Amanda, email — or better yet, write — Beau Chadsworth and accept his standing offer of a job at Harkness. You know how he is about her.”
What Bob Wynant left out, or perhaps was too considerate to mention, was that Tony and his Cousin Amanda Hope-Jackson were not just similar but uncannily alike. Their similarity had been the butt of jokes in the family for years. There was that one incident when they were in high school, he at Milton Academy and she at The Porter School. After the Thanksgiving break each returned to the other’s school — in drag. The masquerade was good enough to fool the respective headmaster and headmistress; good enough, that is, until a vindictive roommate spilled the beans on the eve of the Christmas vacation.
But that was more than twenty years ago. There was a lot of water under the bridge. But there was something else. Tony couldn’t believe that he was giving this ridiculous idea even a moment’s thought. The only reason was Chadsworth. The charming Beau Chadsworth. The gentle, church-going Beau Chadsworth. The philanthropic Beau Chadsworth. For all Tony knew, the criminal mastermind Beau Chadsworth. His childhood chum and sometime college roommate had been bilking Harkness’ investors and the Government out of millions. God only knew how much Chadsworth had salted away in Swiss banks or Hong Kong and Bermuda holding companies. Singapore’s banking system was still shuddering from one of his earlier escapades. In all of this Chadsworth was the current White Knight of corporate America. Some in the Republican Party were already bruiting his name about for public office, very high public office.
What Tony had uncovered about Chadsworth’s dealings had appalled him. Mutual Funds from all the big houses were deeply into Harkness and Tony had felt a mounting ethical dilemma: could he stand idly by and let this all happen? Were those ethics classes at Harvard Business School nothing more than window dressing? The feeling had been growing for more than a year that Tony’s own conscience wouldn’t let him continue with Harkness. It was his greater sense of responsibility that gnawed at him, that made him take Bob Wynant’s idea seriously.
There was something else. Something that few people outside the Harkness inner circle knew, but Tony knew it. Beau Chadsworth was ruthless: he would stop at nothing to keep Harkness and his nefarious schemes going. He had to be stopped. Tony knew that he was the one to do it. Because Chadsworth was so unprincipled, he would pay people to make sure that Tony didn’t talk to the “wrong” people, he would make sure that Tony would never talk to them, never reveal what truly went on at Harkness. He would have Tony killed if he even thought that the secrets might be betrayed.
The risk of exposure, even death was a constant, unwelcome guest in Tony’s thinking. Tony had even seen men he suspected were Chadsworth’s goons down here in North Carolina. The ill-fitting suits and dark glasses were laughably out of place. But Tony also knew that Beau Chadsworth was smarter than that. How about the guy sitting in his car in front of the bait shop in the village. The faded t-shirt and cutoffs were a pretty decent disguise; it’s just that you don’t sit in your car down here for any longer than you have to when it’s 98 degrees in the shade.
It made him nervous this all too casual seaside picnic. Their three cars, all rentals, had North Carolina plates and all of them had been seen on the beach the last couple of days. Their cover seemed plausible enough. He was nervous just the same.
There was a companionable silence that fell over the six people sipping their pinot grigio and merlot. The camambert and the brie were long finished before Tony spoke. “Bob, I’ve been giving this a lot of thought. I won’t lie to you; I’m scared s***less. If for one moment I thought there was another way to nail these guys, I’d grab for it in a heartbeat. As it is, the trade off is a lot worse. With what I’ve shown you, we could scare them, really scare them, but I know them. They would just come up with another bit of brilliant chicanery and we’d be back at square one. If I’m exposed then I’m deader than dead meat; I’d be fricasseed six ways to Sunday. But if I can get in there, and I’m saying ‘if,’ then we might just be able to put them away for good and blow Harkness and its frauds sky high. God help me, I’ll put on a dress and do what has to be done.”
If Tony had thought that everybody would stand up and cheer, he was wrong. His declaration was greeted by a few nods. Everybody was waiting for Bob Wynant. In the fading light they could see the tension manifest in the muscles of his jaw clenching and unclenching. Wynant knew the risks were enormous. He’d been over this territory in his mind, too: a thousand times. Was he sending Tony into the lion’s den to be ground up and spat back out? If Tony were exposed and worse, killed, could he live with himself? There weren’t any easy answers.
“O.K., Tony, you know that you’ll have everybody’s full support. There will be no paper trail for them to follow, except of course for my eyes-only memo to the Director for POTUS.” It made even Wynant nervous to realize how high the stakes were although he tried to maintain his outward composure. Not for nothing Chadsworth had been one of the very largest contributors to the current President’s reelection campaign. He had friends in high places; he made sure they remembered who their friends were. Chadsworth made sure that he and Harkness Holdings were well nigh invulnerable, well, almost.
It wasn’t their invulnerability that Tony was determined to test no matter what the cost to himself. Or to put it another way, it wasn’t knowing where the bodies were buried, but rather knowing who those people had been and what caused Chadsworth and his cronies to bury them in the first place. It was for them, the ones who’d already lost so much in unscrupulous mergers, investors — and employees who’d seen their hopes for a secure retirement melt away, the people who had helped Chadsworth in his climb to the top. These were the ones Chadsworth had systematically destroyed and in at least in two cases Tony suspected had killed. It was for these people that Tony decided to do it. Oh, maybe there were some thoughts of revenge, but he’d had to admit that he wasn’t the one who’d suffered. Oddly, on one level Tony still considered Beau Chadsworth something of a friend. Tony knew any analyst worth his or her salt would have a field day with that.
Another long silence fell over the six of them. Finally, Bob Wynant spoke again. “What I want you to do is take that vacation. The villa in Tuscany is ideal. (He knew that Tony was a pushover for Italy and all things Italian.) Take the rental for a month, six weeks. We’ll have Vanessa Richards of our staff and someone from the agency (Tony thought CIA or one of the lesser known intelligence units.) Join you after a day or two. You’ll get in touch with Amanda and the four of you can spend some time getting better acquainted.” Wynant spoke with a kind of finality in his voice that indicated to everybody that they’d accomplished everything they’d set out to do.
They went back to one of the beachfront houses and grilled some kebabs on the deck and returned to their respective cottages — all on hurricane stilts, of course; the Outer Banks was battered by the big storms year after year. The following morning they all went their separate ways. Tony’s e-ticket and passport and a single suitcase were his only companions as he drove up to Dulles Airport for the flight to Italy later that same evening.
Chapter II
The little villa was on a gentle hill a couple of kilometers from Siena, practically within sight of the graceful spire of the Mangia Tower. In the first few days of his settling in, Tony would bicycle into Siena itself to wander through the Piazza del Campo, browse the art treasures of the Buonsignori Palace or sip one of the magnificent local chiantis. His Italian was rudimentary, but the Sienese were tolerant of him. As much as Tony knew that this little idyll couldn’t last forever, he was determined to enjoy as much of it as he could. Siena may have been a medieval city, but this was still the 21st Century. Cell phones and laptops were everywhere.
Amanda Littleton was the next to arrive. If anyone had thought for a moment that women age less gracefully than men, they clearly had never seen Amanda. Yes, there were more than a few strands of silver among those rich auburn tresses; they just added to the sheen. The tiny crows feet and laugh lines only gentled her alabaster complexion. After their initial embrace Amanda held him by the shoulders. They stood eye to eye. Their adolescent masquerade had depended on it. “Tony, you are a sight for sore eyes. It has been too long, sweetheart. There’s so much we have to talk about.”
“Oh God, Amanda, I’m so happy to see you,” Tony’s eyes glistened as he spoke. He took her hand in his and together they toured their little vacation hideaway. Climbing the narrow stair to the second floor, Tony blurted “Oh Amanda, the minute I see you I realize how much I’ve missed you. It’s like the times when it was just the three of us: you, Cathy and I.” His voice trailed off. Amanda paused, “I know, Sweetie, I know.” She impulsively took her cousin in her arms and held him for a few moments wordlessly. She knew he had not gotten over the death three years ago of his wife, his lover, his best friend, his alter ego, Kathy. There was still no satisfactory explanation of how an otherwise healthy woman, pregnant for the first time at thirty three, could contract preeclampsia and then pass so rapidly into eclampsia. Nor would Tony or Amanda understand how Cathy and the baby would be dead within a matter of days.
The two stood there in Italy and wept, as they had so many times before. Therapy helped, yes, medicines, too. Tony knew and Amanda did too that there would be these times when the cold weight of grief would be too impossible to bear. It just had to be let go. After a few minutes the grief would subside and the tears would stop. Tissues all around. Then the tour could continue. So many people each of them had met in their lives who didn’t understand their closeness, who thought it must be sexual. Cathy’s life first and then her death had made them even closer. George, the remarkable George, Amanda’s husband somehow, miraculously understood. Whatever his reasons, Amanda and Tony were grateful to him. It was George’s great heart that made it possible for Amanda to be with Tony in Italy. Tony’s amazing “predicament,” made it necessary.
They ate their salads on the little patio sitting on the rickety iron chairs that threatened to give way at any moment. “So, Tony, do you want to get started?” Amanda offered as she refreshed her lipstick, gazing into a tiny compact. “Sure, why not,” Tony answered playfully. Impulsively she reached over and covered his lips with color. Instinctively he stiffened. “Tony,” she admonished. “I know it’s been years, but you have done this before and it is a great color on you.” He relaxed. Blotted and sat back. “One small step,...” he quoted. Not satisfied, Amanda pulled off Tony’s shirt and exchanged it for her own. “There. That’s better, AMANDA,” she said prolonging the name for emphasis. Tony laughed good-naturedly.
They’d both had instructions to wait at the villa until Vanessa Richards would join them at the weekend and so they decided to get the transformation process going. The two cousins easily dressed in the other’s clothes and both pretended that this was something of a lark. Just beneath the surface, however, lurked a reality with a far more sinister cast. For a variety of reasons they decided to wait for Vanessa’s arrival before delving too deeply into their individual relationships — one ostensibly romantic and the other strictly business with Beau Chadsworth. Each of them bore more than a little resentment towards Chadsworth, but they realized that the last thing each one wanted to do was to influence their elaborate masquerade with too many bits of old baggage. For now they were content to perform a little “wardrobe realignment” as they called it.
That Friday night they bicycled into Siena each in the other’s clothes to see if they could pass their mutual first test. Tony remembered something from his days studying American history. In the period after World War II, just as the Cold War was beginning, a number of spies from each country infiltrated the other’s borders. The most successful of these weren’t the glamorous defectors who he’d read about on the front page, but rather the quiet, unassuming people who blended in, blended in sometimes to enormous effect. What Tony/Amanda and Amanda/Tony were doing was something like that. Basically trying not to call attention to themselves. They both knew that people saw what they wanted to see. If Tony — the new Amanda — were quiet and unpretentious, and if Amanda — the new Tony — were equally unremarkable, then they passed unnoticed. The very unremarkable stroll that they took in the evening twilight in the Piazza del Campo gave each of them a boost of confidence. Neither of these two had realized just how much it was needed. If Amanda (that is the old Tony) was a bit too direct or if Tony (the old Amanda) was a little reticent, both were well within the bounds of customary behavior. Besides, they obviously were tourists and the locals were long past ignoring a little unusual behavior on the part of their visitors.
“Amanda, dear, (the old Amanda now Tony) said, with more than a touch of amusement, “aren’t you going to freshen your lipstick after that dish of gelato?” Only someone at the next table would have noticed the fleeting murderous glare this comment elicited. “Why, thank you dear, for noticing. You are so observant — for a man ” They both laughed easing any tension. “I’m about ready if you are?” Amanda offered. They mounted their bikes for the short ride back to their villa among the vineyards and olive groves. The evening was turning chilly and Amanda shivered at the unexpected chill on her legs beneath her fluttering skirt.
Upon returning they were too tired to do anything but kiss each other good night. Tony — the old Tony, that is — was glad that their cross dressing experiment was over for the evening. One part of him knew that the full emersion technique was the best way to get into his new role, but he thought it would be best to wait for Vanessa’s arrival the following morning to continue it. If this were to be his last night in boxers and a t-shirt, so be it.
Tony was up early. Maybe it was the good country air, maybe his unspoken anxiety. Puttering around the kitchen, he located the coffee apparatus — more complicated than he was used to — and the aroma of the brewing coffee filled the kitchen and drew his attention away from his bare feet on the cold stone floor. “Hey, sleepyhead,” he greeted Amanda. “Night life too much for you?” She smiled indulgently. “Where’s my breakfast, Signor Buongiorno?” She countered. They bantered back and forth a bit, finding eggs, fruit and cheese to make a good country morning feast. They were just in the clearing stages when they heard a car on the gravel of the driveway. “Vanessa,” they both said in unison.
If either one had a mental picture of Vanessa Richards, it surely did not conform to the image of the person they saw getting out of her late model Fiat Punto. Vanessa wasn’t beautiful by any conventional standard. But you could tell by looking at her that the way she carried herself, her sense of personal style — flair, almost — very nearly made you forget everything else. Simply, Vanessa was a force of nature and there were no two ways about it. She swept into the house and it was all Tony and Amanda could do to keep up with her. She found her way into the kitchen and was pouring herself a cup of coffee before either of her “hosts” had said a word.
“Tony, Amanda, it’s good to meet you,” she began with a smile that was genuine enough, but one that left the clear impression that she was not one to dwell on pleasantries. Her accent was not quite English, perhaps from South Africa or New Zealand. Whatever it had been, its rough edges had been smoothed by travel and god-knows-what-else. “Tony and I wanted to welcome you here, but we’re guests ourselves so perhaps it’s best if we dispense with the formalities,” Amanda offered. “Thanks for that, Amanda,” Vanessa answered, “I think in the interests of time we should get on with the business at hand.” She smiled that same “all-business” smile and turned her attention to Tony. “What they told me was true, Tony, you and Amanda are quite alike. This might not be so difficult as I thought. I’ve read through your biographies that they sent me, but I’m left with a few questions, more than a few questions, really.”
Thus began a conversation that would be spread over the next three weeks. Quite simply, Vanessa wanted to know everything. In those first few minutes, Tony was not quite sure how she did it, but Vanessa dived right into the middle of Amanda’s life. Her utter frankness and brusque kind of charm were a disarming combination. Initially, Amanda was taken aback, but any reticence on her part was speedily dispensed with. This was as clinical as a doctor taking a medical history. Implicit in all Vanessa’s questions was the notion that both Tony and Amanda would have to memorize hundreds of details about each other’s life. Everything from Tony’s first sexual experience in high school to the nature and frequency of Amanda’s periods. The time for squeamishness was long passed. The conversations that first day were mentally exhausting, but it was clear that in order to masquerade as the other, no detail was too small to overlook.
The following Monday the quartet was complete. Tish Miller was a colleague of Vanessa’s from that unnamed Agency. Tish was almost invisible. Perhaps it was the contrast with Vanessa, but Tish seemed to be perpetually in the shadows, even when there weren’t any. As Tony and Amanda were to learn, that was Tish’s particular skill. There was one way in which she resembled Vanessa. For her part Tish was a demanding taskmaster. She was part drill sergeant, part make-up expert and hair stylist. But the thing that Tony came almost to dread was what she anachronistically referred to as “deportment.” It reminded Tony of stories he’d heard as a child about the headmistress of the lower school at Milton Academy: deportment had been her watchword.
What Tish Miller meant by the word was everything that Tony did: from the way he walked to the way he sat. No detail was too small for Tish to notice. Tony was also reminded of his piano teacher, Mrs. Levy. He remembered coming to many a lesson with his piece of the moment not quite mastered; his disobedient fingers would bobble a phrase and he would pray that Mrs. Levy hadn’t heard the tiny error. No such luck. “Mr. Hope-Jackson,” she would begin, all formalities observed, even addressing a recalcitrant seven-year-old, , “please begin with the second measure on page 3. I am not teaching you improvisation today.” It was just like that with Tish. If he got up from the table too suddenly, she would have him sit down again; if his stride were too loose-limbed, she would stop him with a sharply pronounced, “Amanda ” The worst was her invocation of the “real” Amanda. “Now, dear,” Tish would say, “SHE would never do something like that ” More than once Tony was nearly in tears at such reprimands, especially when he’d been trying so hard.
Since he’d left Harkness almost nine months before, Tony hadn’t had his hair cut. Yes, yes, it had been something that he’d been meaning to do, but Jimmy Chen, who used to cut his hair — had cut his hair for years, actually — had gone back to Hong Kong. For once, it seemed, he’d done something Tish liked. “Amanda, dear, your hair is getting lovelier by the day.” Tish trimmed it a few times during their stay in the villa and brought out the natural wave. It really was quite like the “real” Amanda’s hair. For her part Amanda was given a far more mannish cut. To my surprise, Tish and Vanessa had obtained CD’s of me at various conferences and meetings and had studied my repertoire of gestures and mannerisms. I must say that it was very disconcerting to see Amanda, looking more and more like my image every day, walking, speaking and gesturing like me. Then came the meltdown.
It was at the end of the second week, and it caught me totally unawares. It was another beautiful day, the Indian Summer air was still warm and I was enjoying a cup of coffee on the little piazza outside the kitchen. Tish joined me after a few minutes, I turned to her. I forget what I was going to say, but she stopped me with that “look” I’d come to dread. That was all it took. I put my head in my hands and sobbed for all I was worth. She came over to me and gently stroked my back, but that just made things worse and I sobbed all the more. I don’t know when Amanda and Vanessa joined us, but I was crying so hard that I got the hiccups and the next thing I knew hands were gently guiding me inside and up to my room. They eased me down on the bed and took off my shoes; loosening my clothes they covered me with a comforter and quietly tip-toed out.
It must have been late in the afternoon that Amanda looked in on me. The shutters were closed to soften the brilliance of the late afternoon sunlight. I’d lain there for sometime watching the bands of light creeping up the flowered wallpaper. “Sweetie? It’s me,” Amanda began. “How are you feeling?” She seemed content to sit on the edge of the bed for a minute before I answered. “Oh, Amanda, uh Tony, I don’t know what happened out there.” “You don’t have to say anything, Sweetie,” she said, trying to calm me. “No, no, it’s o.k. now. Whatever it was, it has passed. It just caught me off guard and I was about to argue with Tish and the next thing I knew I was in tears and I couldn’t stop. It’s the strangest thing. I just didn’t se it coming, you know?” “Oh, do I ever ” Amanda replied, ruefully. “This playing each other is doing serious things with the inside of my head. You would not believe the dreams I have been having. I just hope that you can get to Beau Chadsworth and at the very least take him down a peg or two.” By this time I was sitting up in bed, my arms clasped around my knees. “Tony,” I said for emphasis, brushing a stray hair out of my eyes, “we’ll do a lot more than take him down a peg. Our old friend — and I use that term loosely — has been raping a pillaging Harkess and everything else he could get his hands on for years. That would be bad enough, but he’s been so sanctimonious about it. If I see his picture at one more charity banquet, I think I’ll go nuts.” Tony laughed relieving the tension that we both still felt from my morning outburst. “Now I know that all this practice is taking hold. “George is constantly teasing me about the latest thing that will cause me “to go nuts.” Apparently, it’s a favorite expression of mine. I didn’t think I said it that often.” Now we both laughed.
“Well, Tony,” I continued, “Beau does make me think that I will go nuts, but it’s even more than that. While you’ll be having the trip of a lifetime in the Himalayas, I’ll be insinuating myself into his inner circle. I may feel a little guilty about the masquerade, but I don’t feel the least guilty about trying to stop him before he steals anything more.” The new Tony nodded in agreement, “You know, Amanda, I remember Beau with a combination of affection and bitterness. There had been a time when we almost got married, as you know. I was the one who got cold feet. I wish I could tell you that it was because I sensed what a crook he was or what a crook he would become, but it wasn’t that. Any woman would be attracted to his combination of powerful man and little-boy vulnerability, to say nothing of those chiseled good looks. What soured me on him — and I’ve only told George and you about this, you understand — was that there was no ‘there there,’ to paraphrase good old Gertrude Stein. There’s this sense of inner emptiness about him. The center isn’t there. We could remain friends, but once I realized that, I couldn’t kid myself: it was the death of anything romantic between us.”
“But it doesn’t look like you ever regretted your decision,” I answered.
“Oh, no I didn’t, even though I didn’t meet George for more than two years after I had stopped seeing Beau. He kept saying that he still wanted us to be friends, but even that had become very difficult for me. We stayed cordial because of our families, his and ours. There would be too many times that we would have to see each other. I knew that Mama and Beau’s parents stayed close for years after that; an open rift between us would have broken their hearts. In fact that it was when we were back home one Christmas... I forget where you were, oh yes, one of those years you worked in Hong Kong and couldn’t get back until the New Year. Well, it was that Christmas and Beau had come down with Christine, that’s right it was the year before they were married. You know the marriage that lasted fifteen months: irreconcilable differences, I think that’s what they said. Well, anyway, Mama and I were talking with Christine, you know, trying to make her feel welcome and Beau came over to us — he was practically bragging to Christine, no wonder she divorced him — “You know, Chrissie, honey (God, he can turn on the southern charm when he wants to) Amanda and I used to be very close, if you know what I mean. Well, I’ve told her this before, but Amanda, anytime you want to bring that fine legal mind of yours up to New York, you call me, I want you in my general counsel’s office. You say yes, and I’ll have you there in a heartbeat.”
“There were more than a few reasons why I turned Beau down about working for him at Harkness. There’s no question, however, that the big one was Beau himself. I think it hurt him more than he said that I didn’t want to work there. And especially after the marriage went south and George and I got together, Beau let it be known that as much as he brushed it off in public there was still some lingering resentment there. Yes, it was some of Beau’s enormous ego — ‘I couldn’t imagine anyone not wanting to work for me — but that was not all of it. Some part of him knew, or had known, that when we broke up he lost something. All this business of ‘a girl in every port’ and ‘women are falling all over themselves to be with me’ just didn’t wash. That’s why he would want to have me work for Harkness because I know him so well. I can anticipate the way he thinks, finish his ideas for him, if you know what I mean.” She finished speaking, her voice almost in a whisper.
Hearing her talk this way was, in a funny way, terribly comforting for the former Tony. Later, much later, he would look back at this conversation and realize that this was something of a watershed. He didn’t know it at the time, but a subtle shift took place. In the course of the conversation the old Tony became the new Amanda, and vice versa. Neither one of them would be able to pinpoint the minute when the change took place, but it was real nonetheless. It was as if the memories of one person exchanged places with the memories of the other. Those conversations that had taken place at family Christmases went from being reported to being remembered. It was very much like the sensation that adult children sometimes have: having heard stories told so many times within a family, they are no longer sure whether they remember the event itself or the reporting of it.
The remaining few days the four friends, for by now they were friends, were able to enjoy their Tuscan holiday. The olive trees and the vineyards were ripe with fruit and the crush of the summer tourists had left the villages less choked with traffic. They all knew that their little idyll was coming to an end. Amanda and Tony knew that their paths would be crossing in the not too distant future, but the same could not be said for Vanessa and Tish. Both of these women were thoroughly professional and had been long accustomed to keep their private and public lives in separate spheres. That being said, however, the final hugs and goodbyes carried with them more than a tinge of regret.
Chapter III
Amanda Littleton’s Alitalia flight landed without event at Dulles Airport one crisp autumn afternoon. The clarity of the air brought the landscape of Northern Virginia into sharp focus. The haze that frequently obscured the gentle serrations of the Blue Ridge Mountains was nowhere in evidence. George Littleton met Amanda at the exit of the International Arrivals. Maybe one of Amanda’s closest friends might have noticed that the embrace and kiss they exchanged was a tad perfunctory, but it anyone else might have put it down to the natural diffidence of a private moment in a public place.
Neither Amanda nor George was under any illusion that the long reach of Beau Chadsworth and Harkness Holdings would have ensured an observer or two at the airport and perhaps even a bug under the dashboard of their Lexus. They kept the conversation general and this allowed George to fill in a lot of details about what had transpired in their suburban lives in her absence.
Their house in Great Falls was a bit of an anomaly. In a landscape dominated by mansions of two sizes, large and enormous, their modest converted farm house was spacious enough for them, but was dwarfed by its neighbors. Amanda certainly did appreciate the newly planted chrysanthemums that lined the drive and created splashes of russet, yellow and cream across the green expanse of lawn. George helped her with her things, Amanda having to remind herself to accept his help rather than be the first to reach for her luggage. Such gestures were more natural to her by the day. They kept their conversations brief and as innocuous as possible. Both had been warned that their house was probably filled with microphones that had been placed by Chadsworth and his minions. George poured them both a glass of chianti classico. As he handed Amanda her glass, he couldn’t help noticing that she got quiet and thoughtful at his little show of remembrance. George and Amanda had spent a memorable holiday in Tuscany and the Abruzzi a few years ago and had both fallen in love with the chiantis. Amanda was touched by his thoughtfulness.
Within a few days their lives fell into a routine. Amanda returned to “her” office at Williams Wesley; her portfolio of clients was in the capable hands of another partner and a team of associates. The long conversations over the past few weeks had proved invaluable in identifying her coworkers and the firm’s clients. This made Amanda’s “review conversations” with her colleagues immensely easier. Williams Wesley had a generous policy of rewarding their partners with ample time to pursue other interests, chiefly charitable work in the areas of debt relief and environmental policy. It was no surprise when, therefore, when Amanda announced her intention to take a longer leave of absence from the firm. She was surprised how easily she fell into the routines of her cousin’s life, even as she knew that it was essential that she do so. There were rafts of emails and phone calls to return and within a week it seemed that the holiday in Tuscany was fading as a distant memory.
Another month went by before Amanda put the next part of their elaborate plan into place. It was only natural to worry that such a plan with so many crucial parts stood little chance of success, but so much depended on her and seeing that the net that she and her law enforcement comrades was poised and ready to ensnare a prey as elusive as Beau Chadsworth. Anyone in the investment world knew how long it had taken to prosecute the scoundrels at Enron. Amanda knew that it would take at least as long to get Beau Chadsworth. Patience, that most difficult of virtues, was to be their watchword.
She’d known her cousin’s (the “real” Amanda) handwriting from countless notes and Christmas cards: theirs was a family who still believed in the sanctity of pen and ink on stationery. Their penmanship was yet another mark of the cousins’ remarkable similarity. “Dear Beau,” her own short letter began, “I’ve taken a little leave of absence from Williams Wesley. I’m going to be in New York at the end of the month between charitable odds and ends I’m working on. Let’s get together for old times’ sake and you can tell me all about you and Harkness. It’s been too long. Love, Amanda.”
She’d dropped the letter off at the McLean Post Office on a Monday. Amanda wasn’t too surprised to get a phone call the following Thursday. “Amanda, darling,” I was so pleased to get your letter.” Beau Chadsworth was simply oozing his famous charm. “Is there any possibility that you could move up your New York visit? I’ve got a string of meetings in London and Brussels at the end of October. I so very much want to see you.” Amanda knew that she had him
Of course, she would see what she could do. “Will you be at the Pierre?” Beau, as suave and sophisticated as ever, was still an eager little boy. His inflection betrayed him. “Well, I suppose so, but it is a bit extravagant, don’t you think, Beau?” “Nothing but the best, honey. Auntie Christine (Amanda’s mother) always said ‘there’s nothing but the best for our Amanda.’” That, too, had been a standing joke left over from Amanda’s childhood. It had become something of a taunt among Amanda’s cousins. But now it served Amanda’s purpose admirably.
They arranged to meet at the Four Seasons. As usual, there was too much activity that blustery autumn afternoon at 2:00, but regular Four Seasons diners knew to expect it. As Amanda, in a role that was both familiar — first cousins with remarkable physical similarities in a large close-knit family — and yet new to her — having so completely changed places with her cousin--, began her conversation with Beau, she felt that only her old fashioned upbringing could be relied upon; everything else was shape-shifting almost before her very eyes. Beau, graciously rising to his feet to greet her, was the same person she had known, but the attention he was paying to her was nothing she had experienced before. She said a silent prayer of thanksgiving for all her preparations in Tuscany. Those few weeks seemed somehow as if they were part of a distant past; all the drilling of mannerisms and habits was almost becoming second nature.
Beau was talking in his smooth, well-oiled way about all the latest achievements of Harkness Holdings. He never spoke about it in the first person; he didn’t have to. Every listener was immediately drawn to the inevitable conclusion that it was all Beau’s doing. That was just what he wanted them to think. Amanda was pleasantly attentive, but inside that well-coifed head
Tony’s mind was going a mile a minute. Beau, happily blathering about his favorite subject — himself — was paying little attention to Amanda. To him she was what he always had to have: an appreciative audience. That was just what Amanda wanted him to think. The cups of espresso came and the two lingered as the dining room of the Four Seasons finally began to clear. The wait staff were used to power lunch couples and gave them no more than the perfunctory attention that was required.
Amanda was listening for the other shoe to drop and drop it finally did. “So Amanda,” Beau finally paused for breath, “does what we’re doing at Harkness sound interesting to you?” He was certain that she would say yes and she didn’t disappoint. “Well, then, why don’t we talk about your taking a little position in our General Counsel’s office. That way I’d have you close by so that I could have the benefit of your legal advice. It wouldn’t bother me at all that you and I would finally be working close together.”
Amanda smiled and laughed good-naturedly. “Why Beau,” she looked down at the tablecloth and looked up at him through her eyelashes. She did everything but bat them at Beau, “I never thought you’d ask. And, Beau, dear, we do need to talk about money. And there’s the little matter of my giving notice at Williams Wesley. They’ve been very good to me. What do you think about my giving them a month and I’ll start with you right after the first of the year?”
Beau made a small shrug as if to say that he supposed he could wait that long. “Well, all right, Amanda, if you insist. I guess I can wait that long. I’ve waited eight years, another month won’t kill me.” Amanda patted his hand affectionately. “And you have someone get in touch with Teddy Markowski, the General Counsel and work out the money. You can pretty much name your price, but I guess you know that.”
A few pleasantries were all that remained and they left the Four Seasons with a chaste hug at the curb as Beau put Amanda in a cab. His car had been waiting at the curb with his liveried driver. Amanda, for her part, waited till the cab turned the corner and Beau was out of sight before reaching for the special cell phone in a small compartment in her purse. It took just seconds for her to send the text message. “It’s done,” was all she wrote. She knew it was all that the prosecutors needed.
Prior to getting his MBA, Tony had taken his JD. He’d never practiced law. Somehow he’d lost the taste for it after passing the New York Bar Exam. But now he was glad that little credential was tucked away in his resume. Nobody would be able to accuse him of practicing law without a license. All this was flashing through Amanda’s mind as she rode in the cab back to the Pierre. Back in her room she placed a call to George’s cell phone. She knew that she couldn’t reach him at his office in the Federal Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia, but he would get his cell phone messages. She had no doubts that her phone was tapped or at the very least her room was bugged. Everything she told George in the voicemail message had been prearranged between the two of them.
When George called a little after six, he was all solicitous concern. He also sounded appropriately enthusiastic at the idea of her getting a job at Harkness Holdings. She’d be back in McLean in a couple of days before getting a place in Manhattan. It would be far from ideal, but they would see each other on the weekends. If any of Beau Chadsworth’s goons noticed that her voice was a little shaky, they probably thought it was a combination of excitement and fatigue. There would be no way that they would realize that Tony Hope Johnson, now so completely disguised as Amanda Littleton, was more than a little nervous. He was going to return to Harkness Holdings and, with any luck, be part of its inner councils. By keeping his eyes and ears open, he would be able to gather enough information to put Beau Chadsworth and his cronies away for a very long time. He had left Harkness earlier in the year disgusted and revolted at the underhanded and no doubt criminal activities that had contributed mightily to the success of the firm. Now he was returning and the prospect of it made his stomach hurt.
Chapter V
Unless you have been subjected to it, it’s hard to imagine the glare of publicity that surrounds a high-profile that took place in Manhattan that Fall. Day after day the defense team filled the nightly news and the Sunday talk shows with their version of events. Rarely did Beau Chadsworth’s attorneys pass up the opportunity to vilify Tony Hope-Johnson a.k.a. Amanda Littleton. Every reference to Tony was tinged with characterizations that bordered on the libelous. Even when the Judge imposed her gag order on the defense and prosecution, these attorneys or their surrogates were out there day after day. The nightly comedy monologues and the comedy news shows all made reference to Tony aka Amanda.
Throughout it all Tony Hope-Johnson gave no interviews, made no statements, responded to no shouted questions. Amanda and George were similarly mute. It took the better part of a year before the reporters and camera people began to lose interest. So many cameras had been outside Tony’s Arlington, Virginia apartment and Amanda and George’s front door that television viewers counted the two residences as among the most recognized in America.
The trial took an inordinate amount of time. In fact the pundits were predicting that after all the pre-trail maneuvering the trial itself might seem anti-climactic. Teams of consultants had been brought in by both sides to prepare every facet. The millions of state and federal dollars spent on the trial passed new records. Throughout it all Chadsworth and his accomplices maintained their innocence. His courtroom performance endeared Chadsworth to some, but infuriated others. In the end the convictions were still stunning. The judge meted out sentences that would leave Chadsworth in a minimum security prison for nearly a quarter of a century; his accomplices fared no better. The monumental fines imposed were earmarked for a fund to compensate employees and investors who had borne the brunt of the monumental swindle Chadsworth and perpetrated.
The inevitable appeals followed, but the most amazing thing was that there was little gloating. Corporate and Financial America had awoken to a new, far chillier day. Even as some in the business world attempted to separate themselves from the excesses of Harkness, it was clear that investors had had enough. The markets slumped into a six-month’s period of “correction.” The high flyers had their wings clipped. They didn’t like it, but their was little sympathy for them. It came to be known as the Chadsworth effect. This would fascinate economists for years to come, but Tony Hope-Johnson couldn’t have cared less.
Anthony Hope-Johnson had other things to contemplate. Life had opened up in ways never imagined. That conversation with Brenda in that New York conference room had been the first quasi-public admission that the changes were deep and anything but trivial. As important as they were, however, Tony knew that the glare of publicity would follow him or her, as Tony began to think of herself. The Harkness business had to settle down completely before he thought that he would be able to stand the publicity.
What Antonia, as she now called herself, did surprised many people. Before doing it, however, she’d gone over it several times with her psychiatrist and with a publicity person her attorney had recommended. The step was unorthodox to say the least, but Antonia had been through a lot and she decided that the best way to handle her transition to living her life as a woman was to go public in a big way. The weekend before the Announcement, as she would think of it afterwards, she spoke with her mother and several close relatives, including Amanda and George Littleton. The following Monday she flew to New York.
She appeared on a comedy news program “It’s to Laugh,” on one of the slightly off-the-wall cable channels. Its host, David Litchfield, was known for his sardonic tongue in cheek approach to news stories. Litchfield attracted an audience that had more or less given up on television news. Appearing on his show was a bold move. Equally bold were her appearances on the two main late night talk shows the following nights. The hosts, led by Litchfield, were one minute serious, and laughing behind their hands the next. Antonia took them in stride. By the end of the interviews, the hosts had all showed their admiration for her courage not only in taking on the challenge of Beau Chadsworth, but of making the change to live her life publically as a woman. As nervous as she felt, she thought this approach would show that she was not ashamed of who she was and was no longer interested in hiding behind a cloak of anonymity. As her attorney had pointed out, prying reporters were determined to “out” her; it was only a matter of time. This way she beat them to the punch.
It wasn’t all a bed of roses, however. The tabloids still made up outrageous stories about her; linking her to one celebrity or another. The fact that she opened a free legal clinic for her “trans sisters,” as she called them, including sex workers, in one of the seedier sections of Los Angeles, only served to fuel their prurient imaginations. It became something of a joke when in a supermarket tabloid splashed a story on its cover identifying her only as “Toni A-J.” It made her laugh.
Her status as a minor celebrity as further enhanced by a character in one of the on-going television police dramas. Commentators noted that this was the first transsexual character on series television.
Antonia Hope-Johnson did go ahead and have her surgery, of course. And thanks to her some other transsexuals began to feel that if she could make the transition and survive and continue to contribute to society, then they could too. Of all the things that she had done, Toni was most proud of this accomplishment.
Deep Cover
Prologue
Harkness Holdings had just posted another astounding quarterly earnings statement that left Wall Street analysts breathless with excitement. The chattering financial commentators were agog. Forbes, Fortune, The Wall Street Journal were all touting the quarter-by-quarter meteoric rise of Beauregard “Beau” Chadsworth, Harkness’ CEO, and his team who’d taken the moribund company and pushed it to the heights of Wall Street stardom. Harkness’ share prices reflected the unbounded confidence of investors big and small. From the get-rich-quick types to the most cautious investors, Harness was what they all wanted.
Beau Chadsworth was the darling of the talk show hosts who outdid one another in their fawning praise. In the post-Enron scandal era, Harkness was basking in its squeaky clean image. And Chadsworth, for his part was all becoming modesty. He was quick to point to the success and support of his team, Jack Levin the COO and Bridget O’Leary the CFO and their subordinates. Then there was the Chadsworth Foundation, already being talked about in the same breath as Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, so recently bolstered by the largess of Warren Buffett.
All was golden in the second and third quarters of 2006. Or so it seemed.
Chapter I
To the casual observer, the scene was ordinary, six friends enjoying a wine and cheese picnic on the white sands of one of those idyllic hamlets along North Carolina’s Outer Banks. They were all dressed for it, too. The women in bright, stylish cover-ups, the men either bare-chested or like Bob Wynant pulling a seersucker hoodie on to ward off the late summer evening’s oncoming chill. The three couples looked to all the world as if they were enjoying a well earned vacation respite from their busy lives.
It was all a sham. Camouflage, really. Tony Jackson, that’s Anthony Hope-Jackson to be precise, was the reason for the charade. You see, Tony was the one person who knew what really went on at Harkness Holdings. He wasn’t exactly a whistle blower, well, at least not yet. Let’s just say the slightly greying, but otherwise fit and trim forty-year old had discovered, that Harkness’ books weren’t exactly “cooked,” but, as he liked to say, “microwaved.” On a doubly encrypted laptop, he had documented schemes within schemes at Harkness to hide massive losses, to shield assets from the prying eyes of Harkness’ accountants, the IRS and the SEC. In a word, a corporate shell game of such breathtaking proportions, that third-world, and even first-world economies would be shaken if it were to be revealed.
What to do? Enter the Fraud Units from the New York State Attorney General’s Office, their counterparts from the State of Delaware, technically the “home” of Harkness and the otherwise somnolent Washington bureaucracies of the FBI and the SEC. Tony Jackson’s problem was how to play the extraordinary hand he had been dealt. If too much of what he knew were to be revealed, all fingers would point to him. Who else knew so much? The various investigators knew that even though Jackson had left Harkness only a few months before, and on the friendliest of terms, the tangled web that was Harkness was becoming more labyrinthine by the moment. The fine line between sharp business practice and outright criminality had been crossed long ago. Tony Jackson was one of the very few people outside Harkness’ inner circle who knew the full extent of the frauds that were being perpetrated.
Tony Jackson, himself beginning to feel the chill, buttoned his faded Hawaiian shirt before leaning back on his elbows, his gaze fixed firmly on the horizon. His “date,” in reality attorney Barbara Morrison, Bob Wynanat and his “wife,” FBI agent Ruth Rabinowitz, were joined by Tara and Bill McKay, of the Delaware AG’s office. Six friends enjoying the fading light of dusk to the accompaniment of the soft splash of the outgoing tide. They faced the water for another reason as well: microphones. Chadsworth had feted Tony on his “retirement” from Harkness to be sure, but Harkness’ high-stakes game made that inner cohort so suspicious that they were not above sending teams to make sure their “friends” were not straying from the fold.
“Tony,” Wynant began, almost in a monotone, “it can work, it should work, it must work. Your family and Chadsworth’s go way back. You yourself told me that at one time he dated your cousin, Amanda. He’s never allowed any woman in his life to get as close to him as she got, not his former wife, not any of his girlfriends. It’s also no secret that you and she look more like twins than cousins. You’ve said so yourself. She’s fine with the idea. You’re the last remaining hurdle.”
As far as Tony was concerned, what Bob Wynant was suggesting was patently absurd. The fact that everybody else on that beach blanket wasn’t contradicting Wynant made him that much more uneasy.
“What you’re saying, Bob, is I should just throw on a dress and go marching into Harkness’ headquarters and demand a job?”
“Not really, Tony,” Bob added, soothingly. “What we want you to do is spend some time with Amanda. Up until a couple of years ago, you used to vacation together, for heaven’s sake. Nothing unusual in that. Take a cruise. Rent a villa in Tuscany for a month. Whatever. And at the end of it, you reemerge as Amanda and Tony — Amanda in male drag — goes trekking in the Himalayas for a while,...something like that. You, as Amanda, email — or better yet, write — Beau Chadsworth and accept his standing offer of a job at Harkness. You know how he is about her.”
What Bob Wynant left out, or perhaps was too considerate to mention, was that Tony and his Cousin Amanda Littleton were not just similar but uncannily alike. Their similarity had been the butt of jokes in the family for years. There was that one incident when they were in high school, he at Milton Academy and she at The Porter School. After the Thanksgiving break each returned to the other’s school — in drag. The masquerade was good enough to fool the respective headmaster and headmistress; good enough, that is, until a vindictive roommate spilled the beans on the eve of the Christmas vacation. But that was more than twenty years ago. There was a lot of water under the bridge.
There was something else. Tony couldn’t believe that he was giving this ridiculous idea even a moment’s thought. The only reason was Chadsworth. The charming Beau Chadsworth. The gentle, church-going Beau Chadsworth. The philanthropic Beau Chadsworth. For all Tony knew, the criminal mastermind Beau Chadsworth. His childhood chum and sometime college roommate had been bilking Harkness’ investors and the Government out of millions. God only knew how much Chadsworth had salted away in Swiss banks or Hong Kong and Bermuda holding companies. Singapore’s banking system was still shuddering from one of his earlier escapades. In all of this Chadsworth was the current White Knight of corporate America. Some in the Republican Party were already bruiting his name about for public office, very high public office.
What Tony had uncovered about Chadsworth’s dealings had appalled him. Mutual Funds from all the big houses were deeply into Harkness and Tony had felt a mounting ethical dilemma: could he stand idly by and let this all happen? Were those ethics classes at Harvard Business School nothing more than window dressing? The feeling had been growing for more than a year that Tony’s own conscience wouldn’t let him continue with Harkness. It was his greater sense of responsibility that gnawed at him, that made him take Bob Wynant’s idea seriously.
Beyond all this there was yet something else. Something that few people outside the Harkness inner circle knew, but Tony knew it. Beau Chadsworth was ruthless: he would stop at nothing to keep Harkness and his nefarious schemes going. He had to be stopped. Tony knew that he was the one to do it. Because Chadsworth was so unprincipled, he would pay people to make sure that Tony didn’t talk to the “wrong” people, he would make sure that Tony would never talk to them, never reveal what truly went on at Harkness. He would have Tony killed if he even thought that the secrets might be betrayed.
The risk of exposure, even death was a constant, unwelcome guest in Tony’s thinking. Tony had even seen men he suspected were Chadsworth’s goons down here in North Carolina. The ill-fitting suits and dark glasses were laughably out of place. But Tony also knew that Beau Chadsworth was smarter than that. How about the guy sitting in his car in front of the bait shop in the village. The faded t-shirt and cutoffs were a pretty decent disguise; it’s just that you don’t sit in your car down here for any longer than you have to when it’s 98 degrees in the shade.
It made him nervous this all too casual seaside picnic. Their three cars, all rentals, had North Carolina plates and all of them had been seen on the beach the last couple of days. Their cover seemed plausible enough. He was nervous just the same.
There was a companionable silence that fell over the six people sipping their pinot grigio and merlot. The camambert and the brie were long finished before Tony spoke.
“Bob, I’ve been giving this a lot of thought. I won’t lie to you; I’m scared s***less. If for one moment I thought there was another way to nail these guys, I’d grab for it in a heartbeat. As it is, the trade off is a lot worse. With what I’ve shown you, we could scare them, really scare them, but I know them. They would just come up with another bit of brilliant chicanery and we’d be back at square one. If I’m exposed then I’m deader than dead meat; I’d be fricasseed six ways to Sunday. But if I can get in there, and I’m saying ‘if,’ then we might just be able to put them away for good and blow Harkness and its frauds sky high. God help me, I’ll put on a dress and do what has to be done.”
If Tony had thought that everybody would stand up and cheer, he was wrong. His declaration was greeted by a few nods. Everybody was waiting for Bob Wynant. In the fading light they could see the tension manifest in the muscles of his jaw clenching and unclenching. Wynant knew the risks were enormous. He’d been over this territory in his mind, too: a thousand times. Was he sending Tony into the lion’s den to be ground up and spat back out? If Tony were exposed and worse, killed, could he live with himself? There weren’t any easy answers.
“O.K., Tony, you know that you’ll have everybody’s full support. There will be no paper trail for them to follow, except of course for my eyes-only memo to the Director for POTUS.” It made even Wynant nervous to realize how high the stakes were although he tried to maintain his outward composure. Not for nothing Chadsworth had been one of the very largest contributors to the current President’s reelection campaign. He had friends in high places; he made sure they remembered who their friends were. Chadsworth made sure that he and Harkness Holdings were well nigh invulnerable, well, almost.
It wasn’t their invulnerability that Tony was determined to test no matter what the cost to himself. Or to put it another way, it wasn’t knowing where the bodies were buried, but rather knowing who those people had been and what caused Chadsworth and his cronies to bury them in the first place. It was for them, the ones who’d already lost so much in unscrupulous mergers, investors — and employees who’d seen their hopes for a secure retirement melt away, the people who had helped Chadsworth in his climb to the top. These were the ones Chadsworth had systematically destroyed and in at least in two cases Tony suspected had killed. It was for these people that Tony decided to do it. Oh, maybe there were some thoughts of revenge, but he’d had to admit that he wasn’t the one who’d suffered. Oddly, on one level Tony still considered Beau Chadsworth something of a friend. Tony knew any analyst worth his or her salt would have a field day with that.
Another long silence fell over the six of them. Finally, Bob Wynant spoke again.
“What I want you to do is take that vacation. The villa in Tuscany is ideal. (He knew that Tony was a pushover for Italy and all things Italian.) Take the rental for a month, six weeks. We’ll have Vanessa Richards of our staff and someone from the agency (Tony thought CIA or one of the lesser known intelligence units.) Join you after a day or two. You’ll get in touch with Amanda and the four of you can spend some time getting better acquainted.” Wynant spoke with a kind of finality in his voice that indicated to everybody that they’d accomplished everything they’d set out to do.
They went back to one of the beachfront houses and grilled some kebabs on the deck and returned to their respective cottages — all on hurricane stilts, of course; the Outer Banks was battered by the big storms year after year. The following morning they all went their separate ways. Tony’s e-ticket and passport and a single suitcase were his only companions as he drove up to Dulles Airport for the flight to Italy later that same evening.
Chapter II
The little villa was on a gentle hill a couple of kilometers from Siena, practically within sight of the graceful spire of the Mangia Tower. In the first few days of his settling in, Tony would bicycle into Siena itself to wander through the Piazza del Campo, browse the art treasures of the Buonsignori Palace or sip one of the magnificent local chiantis. His Italian was rudimentary, but the Sienese were tolerant of him. As much as Tony knew that this little idyll couldn’t last forever, he was determined to enjoy as much of it as he could. Siena may have been a medieval city, but this was still the 21st Century. Cell phones and laptops were everywhere.
Amanda Littleton was the next to arrive. If anyone had thought for a moment that women age less gracefully than men, they clearly had never seen Amanda. Yes, there were more than a few strands of silver among those rich auburn tresses; they just added to the sheen. The tiny crows feet and laugh lines only gentled her alabaster complexion. After their initial embrace Amanda held him by the shoulders. They stood eye to eye. Their adolescent masquerade had depended on it.
“Tony, you are a sight for sore eyes,” she said. “It has been too long, sweetheart. There’s so much we have to talk about.”
“Oh God, Amanda, I’m so happy to see you,” Tony’s eyes glistened as he spoke. He took her hand in his and together they toured their little vacation hideaway. Climbing the narrow stair to the second floor, Tony blurted “Oh Amanda, the minute I see you I realize how much I’ve missed you. It’s like the times when it was just the three of us: you, Cathy and I.” His voice trailed off.
Amanda paused, “I know, Sweetie, I know.” She impulsively took her cousin in her arms and held him for a few moments wordlessly. She knew he had not gotten over the death three years ago of his wife, his lover, his best friend, his alter ego, Kathy. There was still no satisfactory explanation of how an otherwise healthy woman, pregnant for the first time at thirty three, could contract preeclampsia and then pass so rapidly into eclampsia. Nor would Tony or Amanda understand how Cathy and the baby would be dead within a matter of days.
The two stood there in Italy and wept, as they had so many times before. Therapy helped, yes, medicines, too. Tony knew and Amanda did too that there would be these times when the cold weight of grief would be too impossible to bear. It just had to be let go. After a few minutes the grief would subside and the tears would stop. Tissues all around. Then the tour could continue. So many people each of them had met in their lives who didn’t understand their closeness, who thought it must be sexual. Cathy’s life first and then her death had made them even closer. George, the remarkable George, Amanda’s husband somehow, miraculously understood. Whatever his reasons, Amanda and Tony were grateful to him. It was George’s great heart that made it possible for Amanda to be with Tony in Italy. Tony’s amazing “predicament,” made it necessary.
They ate their salads on the little patio sitting on the rickety iron chairs that threatened to give way at any moment.
“So, Tony, do you want to get started?” Amanda offered as she refreshed her lipstick, gazing into a tiny compact.
“Sure, why not,” Tony answered playfully. Impulsively she reached over and covered his lips with color. Instinctively he stiffened.
“Tony,” she admonished. “I know it’s been years, but you have done this before and it is a great color on you.” He relaxed. Blotted and sat back.
“One small step,...” he quoted. Not satisfied, Amanda pulled off Tony’s shirt and exchanged it for her own.
“There. That’s better, AMANDA,” she said prolonging the name for emphasis. Tony laughed good-naturedly.
They’d both had instructions to wait at the villa until Vanessa Richards would join them at the weekend and so they decided to get the transformation process going. The two cousins easily dressed in the other’s clothes and both pretended that this was something of a lark. Just beneath the surface, however, lurked a reality with a far more sinister cast. For a variety of reasons they decided to wait for Vanessa’s arrival before delving too deeply into their individual relationships — one ostensibly romantic and the other strictly business with Beau Chadsworth. Each of them bore more than a little resentment towards Chadsworth, but they realized that the last thing each one wanted to do was to influence their elaborate masquerade with too many bits of old baggage. For now they were content to perform a little “wardrobe realignment” as they called it.
That Friday night they bicycled into Siena each in the other’s clothes to see if they could pass their mutual first test. Tony remembered something from his days studying American history. In the period after World War II, just as the Cold War was beginning, a number of spies from each country infiltrated the other’s borders. The most successful of these weren’t the glamorous defectors who he’d read about on the front page, but rather the quiet, unassuming people who blended in, blended in sometimes to enormous effect. What Tony/Amanda and Amanda/Tony were doing was something like that. Basically trying not to call attention to themselves. They both knew that people saw what they wanted to see. If Tony — the new Amanda — were quiet and unpretentious, and if Amanda — the new Tony — were equally unremarkable, then they passed unnoticed. The very unremarkable stroll that they took in the evening twilight in the Piazza del Campo gave each of them a boost of confidence. Neither of these two had realized just how much it was needed. If Amanda (that is the old Tony) was a bit too direct or if Tony (the old Amanda) was a little reticent, both were well within the bounds of customary behavior. Besides, they obviously were tourists and the locals were long past ignoring a little unusual behavior on the part of their visitors.
“Amanda, dear, (the old Amanda now Tony) said, with more than a touch of amusement, “aren’t you going to freshen your lipstick after that dish of gelato?” Only someone at the next table would have noticed the fleeting murderous glare this comment elicited.
“Why, thank you dear, for noticing. You are so observant — for a man ” They both laughed easing any tension.
“I’m about ready if you are?” Amanda offered. They mounted their bikes for the short ride back to their villa among the vineyards and olive groves. The evening was turning chilly and Amanda shivered at the unexpected chill on her legs beneath her fluttering skirt.
Upon returning they were too tired to do anything but kiss each other good night. Tony — the old Tony, that is — was glad that their cross dressing experiment was over for the evening. One part of him knew that the full emersion technique was the best way to get into his new role, but he thought it would be best to wait for Vanessa’s arrival the following morning to continue it. If this were to be his last night in boxers and a t-shirt, so be it.
Tony was up early. Maybe it was the good country air, maybe his unspoken anxiety. Puttering around the kitchen, he located the coffee apparatus — more complicated than he was used to — and the aroma of the brewing coffee filled the kitchen and drew his attention away from his bare feet on the cold stone floor.
“Hey, sleepyhead,” he greeted Amanda. “Night life too much for you?”
She smiled indulgently. “Where’s my breakfast, Signor Buongiorno?” She countered. They bantered back and forth a bit, finding eggs, fruit and cheese to make a good country morning feast. They were just in the clearing stages when they heard a car on the gravel of the driveway. “Vanessa,” they both said in unison.
If either one had a mental picture of Vanessa Richards, it surely did not conform to the image of the person they saw getting out of her late model Fiat Punto. Vanessa wasn’t beautiful by any conventional standard. But you could tell by looking at her that the way she carried herself, her sense of personal style — flair, almost — very nearly made you forget everything else. Simply, Vanessa was a force of nature and there were no two ways about it. She swept into the house and it was all Tony and Amanda could do to keep up with her. She found her way into the kitchen and was pouring herself a cup of coffee before either of her “hosts” had said a word.
“Tony, Amanda, it’s good to meet you,” she began with a smile that was genuine enough, but one that left the clear impression that she was not one to dwell on pleasantries. Her accent was not quite English, perhaps from South Africa or New Zealand. Whatever it had been, its rough edges had been smoothed by travel and god-knows-what-else.
“Tony and I wanted to welcome you here, but we’re guests ourselves so perhaps it’s best if we dispense with the formalities,” Amanda offered.
“Thanks for that, Amanda,” Vanessa answered, “I think in the interests of time we should get on with the business at hand.” She smiled that same “all-business” smile and turned her attention to Tony.
“What they told me was true, Tony, you and Amanda are quite alike. This might not be so difficult as I thought. I’ve read through your biographies that they sent me, but I’m left with a few questions, more than a few questions, really.”
Thus began a conversation that would be spread over the next three weeks. Quite simply, Vanessa wanted to know everything. In those first few minutes, Tony was not quite sure how she did it, but Vanessa dived right into the middle of Amanda’s life. Her utter frankness and brusque kind of charm were a disarming combination. Initially, Amanda was taken aback, but any reticence on her part was speedily dispensed with. This was as clinical as a doctor taking a medical history. Implicit in all Vanessa’s questions was the notion that both Tony and Amanda would have to memorize hundreds of details about each other’s life. Everything from Tony’s first sexual experience in high school to the nature and frequency of Amanda’s periods. The time for squeamishness was long passed. The conversations that first day were mentally exhausting, but it was clear that in order to masquerade as the other, no detail was too small to overlook.
The following Monday the quartet was complete. Tish Miller was a colleague of Vanessa’s from that unnamed Agency. Tish was almost invisible. Perhaps it was the contrast with Vanessa, but Tish seemed to be perpetually in the shadows, even when there weren’t any. As Tony and Amanda were to learn, that was Tish’s particular skill. There was one way in which she resembled Vanessa. For her part Tish was a demanding taskmaster. She was part drill sergeant, part make-up expert and hair stylist. But the thing that Tony came almost to dread was what she anachronistically referred to as “deportment.” It reminded Tony of stories he’d heard as a child about the headmistress of the lower school at Milton Academy: deportment had been her watchword.
What Tish Miller meant by the word was everything that Tony did: from the way he walked to the way he sat. No detail was too small for Tish to notice. Tony was also reminded of his piano teacher, Mrs. Levy. He remembered coming to many a lesson with his piece of the moment not quite mastered; his disobedient fingers would bobble a phrase and he would pray that Mrs. Levy hadn’t heard the tiny error. No such luck.
“Mr. Hope-Jackson,” she would begin, all formalities observed, even addressing a recalcitrant seven-year-old, , “please begin with the second measure on page 3. I am not teaching you improvisation today.”
It was just like that with Tish. If he got up from the table too suddenly, she would have him sit down again; if his stride were too loose-limbed, she would stop him with a sharply pronounced, “Amanda ” The worst was her invocation of the “real” Amanda. “Now, dear,” Tish would say, “SHE would never do something like that ” More than once Tony was nearly in tears at such reprimands, especially when he’d been trying so hard.
Since he’d left Harkness almost nine months before, Tony hadn’t had his hair cut. Yes, yes, it had been something that he’d been meaning to do, but Jimmy Chen, who used to cut his hair — had cut his hair for years, actually — had gone back to Hong Kong. For once, it seemed, he’d done something Tish liked.
“Amanda, dear, your hair is getting lovelier by the day.” Tish trimmed it a few times during their stay in the villa and brought out the natural wave. It really was quite like the “real” Amanda’s hair. For her part Amanda was given a far more mannish cut. To Tony’s surprise, Tish and Vanessa had obtained CD’s of him at various conferences and meetings and had studied his repertoire of gestures and mannerisms. Tony found it very disconcerting to see Amanda, looking more and more like his image every day, walking, speaking and gesturing like him. Then came the meltdown.
It was at the end of the second week, and it caught Tony totally unawares. It was another beautiful day, the Indian Summer air was still warm and he was enjoying a cup of coffee on the little piazza outside the kitchen. Tish joined him after a few minutes, Tony turned to her. Later he had forgotten what he was going to say, but she stopped him with that “look” he’d come to dread. That was all it took. Tony put his head in his hands and sobbed for all he was worth. Tish came over to him and gently stroked his back, but that just made things worse and he sobbed all the more. Amanda and Vanessa silently joined them, but Tony was crying so hard that he got the hiccups and the next thing he knew hands were gently guiding him inside and up to his room. They eased him down on the bed and took off his shoes; loosening his clothes they covered him with a comforter and quietly tip-toed out.
It must have been late in the afternoon that Amanda looked in on him. The shutters were closed to soften the brilliance of the late afternoon sunlight. Tony had lain there for sometime watching the bands of light creeping up the flowered wallpaper.
“Sweetie? It’s me,” Amanda began. “How are you feeling?” She seemed content to sit on the edge of the bed for a minute before he answered.
“Oh, Amanda, uh Tony, I don’t know what happened out there.”
“You don’t have to say anything, Sweetie,” she said, trying to calm him.
“No, no, it’s o.k. now. Whatever it was, it has passed. It just caught me off guard and I was about to argue with Tish and the next thing I knew I was in tears and I couldn’t stop. It’s the strangest thing. I just didn’t se it coming, you know?”
“Oh, do I ever ” Amanda replied, ruefully. “This playing each other is doing serious things with the inside of my head. You would not believe the dreams I have been having. I just hope that you can get to Beau Chadsworth and at the very least take him down a peg or two.”
By this time Tony was sitting up in bed, his arms clasped around his knees. “Tony,” he said for emphasis, brushing a stray hair out of his eyes, “we’ll do a lot more than take him down a peg. Our old friend — and I use that term loosely — has been raping a pillaging Harkess and everything else he could get his hands on for years. That would be bad enough, but he’s been so sanctimonious about it. If I see his picture at one more charity banquet, I think I’ll go nuts.”
Tony laughed relieving the tension that we both still felt from that morning’s outburst. “Now I know that all this practice is taking hold. “George is constantly teasing me about the latest thing that will cause me “to go nuts.” Apparently, it’s a favorite expression of mine. I didn’t think I said it that often.” Now we both laughed.
“Well, Tony,” he continued, “Beau does make me think that I will go nuts, but it’s even more than that. While you’ll be having the trip of a lifetime in the Himalayas, I’ll be insinuating myself into his inner circle. I may feel a little guilty about the masquerade, but I don’t feel the least bit guilty about trying to stop him before he steals anything more.”
The new Tony nodded in agreement, “You know, Amanda, I remember Beau with a combination of affection and bitterness. There had been a time when we almost got married, as you know. I was the one who got cold feet. I wish I could tell you that it was because I sensed what a crook he was or what a crook he would become, but it wasn’t that. Any woman would be attracted to his combination of powerful man and little-boy vulnerability, to say nothing of those chiseled good looks. What soured me on him — and I’ve only told George and you about this, you understand — was that there was no ‘there there,’ to paraphrase good old Gertrude Stein. There’s this sense of inner emptiness about him. The center isn’t there. We could remain friends, but once I realized that, I couldn’t kid myself: it was the death of anything romantic between us.”
“But it doesn’t look like you ever regretted your decision,” Tony answered.
“Oh, no I didn’t, even though I didn’t meet George for more than two years after I had stopped seeing Beau. He kept saying that he still wanted us to be friends, but even that had become very difficult for me. We stayed cordial because of our families, his and ours. There would be too many times that we would have to see each other. I knew that Mama and Beau’s parents stayed close for years after that; an open rift between us would have broken their hearts. In fact that it was when we were back home one Christmas... I forget where you were, oh yes, one of those years you worked in Hong Kong and couldn’t get back until the New Year. Well, it was that Christmas and Beau had come down with Christine, that’s right it was the year before they were married. You know the marriage that lasted fifteen months: irreconcilable differences, I think that’s what they said.
Well, anyway, Mama and I were talking with Christine, you know, trying to make her feel welcome and Beau came over to us — he was practically bragging to Christine, no wonder she divorced him — “You know, Chrissie, honey (God, he can turn on the southern charm when he wants to) Amanda and I used to be very close, if you know what I mean. Well, I’ve told her this before, but Amanda, anytime you want to bring that fine legal mind of yours up to New York, you call me, I want you in my general counsel’s office. You say yes, and I’ll have you there in a heartbeat.”
“There were more than a few reasons why I turned Beau down about working for him at Harkness. There’s no question, however, that the big one was Beau himself. I think it hurt him more than he said that I didn’t want to work there. And especially after the marriage went south and George and I got together, Beau let it be known that as much as he brushed it off in public there was still some lingering resentment there. Yes, it was some of Beau’s enormous ego — ‘I couldn’t imagine anyone not wanting to work for me — but that was not all of it. Some part of him knew, or had known, that when we broke up he lost something. All this business of ‘a girl in every port’ and ‘women are falling all over themselves to be with me’ just didn’t wash. That’s why he would want to have me work for Harkness because I know him so well. I can anticipate the way he thinks, finish his ideas for him, if you know what I mean.” She finished speaking, her voice almost in a whisper.
Hearing her talk this way was, in a funny way, terribly comforting for the former Tony. Later, much later, he would look back at this conversation and realize that this was something of a watershed. He didn’t know it at the time, but a subtle shift took place. In the course of the conversation the old Tony became the new Amanda, and vice versa. Neither one of them would be able to pinpoint the minute when the change took place, but it was real nonetheless. It was as if the memories of one person exchanged places with the memories of the other. Those conversations that had taken place at family Christmases went from being reported to being remembered. It was very much like the sensation that adult children sometimes have: having heard stories told so many times within a family, they are no longer sure whether they remember the event itself or the reporting of it.
The remaining few days the four friends, for by now they were friends, were able to enjoy their Tuscan holiday. The olive trees and the vineyards were ripe with fruit and the crush of the summer tourists had left the villages less choked with traffic. They all knew that their little idyll was coming to an end. Amanda and Tony knew that their paths would be crossing in the not too distant future, but the same could not be said for Vanessa and Tish. Both of these women were thoroughly professional and had been long accustomed to keep their private and public lives in separate spheres. That being said, however, the final hugs and goodbyes carried with them more than a tinge of regret.
Chapter III
Amanda Littleton’s Alitalia flight landed without event at Dulles Airport one crisp autumn afternoon. The clarity of the air brought the landscape of Northern Virginia into sharp focus. The haze that frequently obscured the gentle serrations of the Blue Ridge Mountains was nowhere in evidence. George Littleton met Amanda at the exit of the International Arrivals. Maybe one of Amanda’s closest friends might have noticed that the embrace and kiss they exchanged was a tad perfunctory, but it anyone else might have put it down to the natural diffidence of a private moment in a public place.
Neither Amanda nor George was under any illusion that the long reach of Beau Chadsworth and Harkness Holdings would have ensured an observer or two at the airport and perhaps even a bug under the dashboard of their Lexus. They kept the conversation general and this allowed George to fill in a lot of details about what had transpired in their suburban lives in her absence.
Their house in Great Falls was a bit of an anomaly. In a landscape dominated by mansions of two sizes, large and enormous, their modest converted farm house was spacious enough for them, but was dwarfed by its neighbors. Amanda certainly did appreciate the newly planted chrysanthemums that lined the drive and created splashes of russet, yellow and cream across the green expanse of lawn. George helped her with her things, Amanda having to remind herself to accept his help rather than be the first to reach for her luggage. Such gestures were more natural to her by the day. They kept their conversations brief and as innocuous as possible. Both had been warned that their house was probably filled with microphones that had been placed by Chadsworth and his minions. George poured them both a glass of chianti classico. As he handed Amanda her glass, he couldn’t help noticing that she got quiet and thoughtful at his little show of remembrance. George and Amanda had spent a memorable holiday in Tuscany and the Abruzzi a few years ago and had both fallen in love with the chiantis. Amanda was touched by his thoughtfulness.
Within a few days their lives fell into a routine. Amanda returned to “her” office at Williams Wesley; her portfolio of clients was in the capable hands of another partner and a team of associates. The long conversations over the past few weeks had proved invaluable in identifying her coworkers and the firm’s clients. This made Amanda’s “review conversations” with her colleagues immensely easier. Williams Wesley had a generous policy of rewarding their partners with ample time to pursue other interests, chiefly charitable work in the areas of debt relief and environmental policy. It was no surprise when, therefore, when Amanda announced her intention to take a longer leave of absence from the firm. She was surprised how easily she fell into the routines of her cousin’s life, even as she knew that it was essential that she do so. There were rafts of emails and phone calls to return and within a week it seemed that the holiday in Tuscany was fading as a distant memory.
Another month went by before Amanda put the next part of their elaborate plan into place. It was only natural to worry that such a plan with so many crucial parts stood little chance of success, but so much depended on her seeing that the net that she and her law enforcement comrades was poised and ready to ensnare a prey as elusive as Beau Chadsworth. Anyone in the investment world knew how long it had taken to prosecute the scoundrels at Enron. Amanda knew that it would take at least as long to get Beau Chadsworth. Patience, that most difficult of virtues, was to be their watchword.
She’d known her cousin’s (the “real” Amanda) handwriting from countless notes and Christmas cards: theirs was a family who still believed in the sanctity of pen and ink on stationery. Their penmanship was yet another mark of the cousins’ remarkable similarity. “Dear Beau,” her own short letter began, “I’ve taken a little leave of absence from Williams Wesley. I’m going to be in New York at the end of the month between charitable odds and ends I’m working on. Let’s get together for old times’ sake and you can tell me all about you and Harkness. It’s been too long. Love, Amanda.”
She’d dropped the letter off at the McLean Post Office on a Monday. Amanda wasn’t too surprised to get a phone call the following Thursday. “Amanda, darling,” I was so pleased to get your letter.” Beau Chadsworth was simply oozing his famous charm. “Is there any possibility that you could move up your New York visit? I’ve got a string of meetings in London and Brussels at the end of October. I so very much want to see you.” Amanda knew that she had him
Of course, she would see what she could do.
“Will you be at the Pierre?” Beau, as suave and sophisticated as ever, was still an eager little boy. His inflection betrayed him.
“Well, I suppose so, but it is a bit extravagant, don’t you think, Beau?”
“Nothing but the best for our Amanda, honey.” Auntie Christine (Amanda’s mother) always said ‘there’s nothing but the best for our Amanda.’ That, too, had been a standing joke left over from Amanda’s childhood. It had become something of a taunt among Amanda’s cousins. But now it served Amanda’s purpose admirably.
They arranged to meet at the Four Seasons. As usual, there was too much activity that blustery autumn afternoon at 2:00, but regular Four Seasons diners knew to expect it. As Amanda, in a role that was both familiar — first cousins with remarkable physical similarities in a large close-knit family — and yet new to her — having so completely changed places with her cousin--, began her conversation with Beau, she felt that only her old fashioned upbringing could be relied upon; everything else was shape-shifting almost before her very eyes. Beau, graciously rising to his feet to greet her, was the same person she had known, but the attention he was paying to her was nothing she had experienced before. She said a silent prayer of thanksgiving for all her preparations in Tuscany. Those few weeks seemed somehow as if they were part of a distant past; all the drilling of mannerisms and habits was almost becoming second nature.
Beau was talking in his smooth, well-oiled way about all the latest achievements of Harkness Holdings. He never spoke about it in the first person; he didn’t have to. Every listener was immediately drawn to the inevitable conclusion that it was all Beau’s doing. That was just what he wanted them to think. Amanda was pleasantly attentive, but inside that well-coifed head
Tony’s mind was going a mile a minute. Beau, happily blathering about his favorite subject — himself — was paying little attention to Amanda. To him she was what he always had to have: an appreciative audience. That was just what Amanda wanted him to think. The cups of espresso came and the two lingered as the dining room of the Four Seasons finally began to clear. The wait staff were used to power lunch couples and gave them no more than the perfunctory attention that was required.
Amanda was listening for the other shoe to drop and drop it finally did.
“So Amanda,” Beau finally paused for breath, “does what we’re doing at Harkness sound interesting to you?” He was certain that she would say yes and she didn’t disappoint. “Well, then, why don’t we talk about your taking a little position in our General Counsel’s office. That way I’d have you close by so that I could have the benefit of your legal advice. It wouldn’t bother me at all that you and I would finally be working close together.”
Amanda smiled and laughed good-naturedly. “Why Beau,” she looked down at the tablecloth and looked up at him through her eyelashes. She did everything but bat them at Beau, “I never thought you’d ask. And, Beau, dear, we do need to talk about money. And there’s the little matter of my giving notice at Williams Wesley. They’ve been very good to me. What do you think about my giving them a month and I’ll start with you right after the first of the year?”
Beau made a small shrug as if to say that he supposed he could wait that long. “Well, all right, Amanda, if you insist. I guess I can wait that long. I’ve waited eight years, another month won’t kill me.” Amanda patted his hand affectionately. “And you have someone get in touch with Teddy Markowski, the General Counsel and work out the money. You can pretty much name your price, but I guess you know that.”
A few pleasantries were all that remained and they left the Four Seasons with a chaste hug at the curb as Beau put Amanda in a cab. His car had been waiting at the curb with his liveried driver. Amanda, for her part, waited till the cab turned the corner and Beau was out of sight before reaching for the special cell phone in a small compartment in her purse. It took just seconds for her to send the text message. “It’s done,” was all she wrote. She knew it was all that the prosecutors needed.
Prior to getting his MBA, Tony Hope-Jackson had taken his JD. He’d never practiced law. Somehow he’d lost the taste for it after passing the New York Bar Exam. But now Amanda was glad that little credential was tucked away in the resume. Nobody would be able to accuse her of practicing law without a license. All this was flashing through Amanda’s mind as she rode in the cab back to the Pierre. Back in her room she placed a call to George’s cell phone. She knew that she couldn’t reach him at his office in the Federal Courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia, but he would get his cell phone messages. She had no doubts that her phone was tapped or at the very least her room was bugged. Everything she told George in the voicemail message had been prearranged between the two of them.
When George called a little after six, he was all solicitous concern. He also sounded appropriately enthusiastic at the idea of her getting a job at Harkness Holdings. She’d be back in McLean in a couple of days before getting a place in Manhattan. It would be far from ideal, but they would see each other on the weekends. If any of Beau Chadsworth’s goons noticed that her voice was a little shaky, they probably thought it was a combination of excitement and fatigue. There would be no way that they would realize that Tony Hope Johnson, now so completely disguised as Amanda Littleton, was more than a little nervous. He was going to return to Harkness Holdings and, with any luck, be part of its inner councils. By keeping his eyes and ears open, he would be able to gather enough information to put Beau Chadsworth and his cronies away for a very long time. He had left Harkness earlier in the year disgusted and revolted at the underhanded and no doubt criminal activities that had contributed mightily to the success of the firm. Now he was returning and the prospect of it made his stomach hurt.
Chapter IV
The shuttle flight back to DCA was boring, but brief. Bob Wynant, Amanda’s “minder” from the New York State Attorney General’s office had arranged it all. Clutching her purse, her laptop and a light coat against the chill, Amanda waited at the curb for the ride she was expecting from her ‘neighbor.’ That new neighbor had purchased the house across from hers on the quiet cul-de-sac in McLean, Virginia. She’d just dropped her husband at Regan National; it was only a neighborly thing to do to pick up Amanda as a favor to Amanda’s husband George.
Amanda hadn’t met the neighbor before, but George had vouched for her. The advantage was that Chadsworth’s goons wouldn’t have had time to plant a bug in the neighbor’s car. This meant that Amanada — the deeply disguised Anthony Hope-Jackson — would be able to brief the neighbor, Bob Wynant’s young assistant, Brenda Richards during the half hour journey home.
“Hi, Amanda,” I’m Brenda, she offered cheerily. “George has told us so much about you, I’ve been dying to meet you. I’m so looking forward to our becoming friends.”
Amanda, was as genuinely gracious as her Southern upbringing permitted. When they had passed the airport’s outer perimeter, the real conversation began.
“Well, Brenda,” Amanda began, “Beau Chadsworth took the bait. Our lunch at the Four Seasons was just what we thought it would be. I’ve got to tell you, though, there’s something about Beau that I find very creepy. All those years I worked at Harkness, it was there at the back of my mind, but now, dressed like this,” she gestured at her crisply tailored suit and Manolo Blahnik’s, “it makes my skin crawl.”
“Do you think that he suspects something,” Brenda wondered. “Doesn’t he recognize Tony in all of this?”
“To be perfectly honest with you, for all his business acumen, Beau can be incredibly dense. I’d never paid that much attention to it before, but all I had to do was sit there and hang on every word that he said and he wouldn’t have noticed if I had been dancing on the table stark naked.”
The two chatted and laughed all the way to Amanda and George’s house. It was one of many “chance” conversations that they would have. Sometimes in the nearby Tyson’s Corner Mall’s sprawling parking garages, other times at the Great Falls Park. Two women strolling together, window shopping or taking in the local sights. It was the mechanism of choice for the passing of the data that Amanda systematically collected over the next thirteen months. Over that time Amanda and Brenda’s friendship grew and that didn’t become a problem exactly, but it sounded a signal to Amanda that, though faint at first, grew to something that she couldn’t ignore. But that’s for a later part of our story.
In the meantime the legal noose around the neck of Beau Chadsworth grew tighter. By this time, dear reader, I am sure that you cannot have escaped the story of the unraveling of Harkness Holdings and the downfall of Beau Chadsworth. I won’t bother to repeat this oft-told story. There have been at least half a dozen books, a documentary film and a fictionalized account that lay out the sordid details for all the world to see. All the while Chadsworth and his accomplices proclaimed their innocence and asserted brazenly that not only were their actions perfectly legal, but that if they had been allowed to carry them to their logical conclusion would have resulted in windfall profits for their shareholders.
The legal teams would be spending the next two years assembling their mountains of evidence which would result in the convictions of Chadsworth and his most trusted inner circle. Conspicuously absent from the indictments, however, were the names of Anthony Hope-Jackson and Amanda Littleton. The teams of attorneys assembled by Chadsworth and his people were initially perplexed at this. Weren’t Tony Hope-Jackson and later Amanda Littleton up to their ears in what the Government called this conspiracy? Nobody was rushing forward with offers of plea bargains and so the defendants’ attorneys began to smell a rat or perhaps more than one.
It was nearly a year after Beau Chadsworth’s spectacular arrest and the sight of him on the nightly news walking from the courthouse in his three thousand dollar suit and seventy-five dollar handcuffs, that Tony — the real Tony, that is — got a call from Bob Wynant’s office.
“Tony,” the voice began, “I’ve got Brenda here with me on conference call. We need to talk about a few things.”
“Yes, I know,” Tony answered resignedly, “I’ve been expecting this call.”
“When we came up with this idea, , Wynant continued, “we never really discussed the final outcome. I wanted to, well... both of us wanted to prepare you for deposition and testimony. And especially there will have to be some public statements. I think that we need to talk about this at some length. Do you want us to come to Virginia or would you be willing to come back up to the City?” To New Yorkers, “The City” meant New York City; there clearly was no other urban entity that merited that designation. Tony smiled to himself; he’d never become a Manhattan-ite despite the years he’d spent there.
“No, that’s fine,” he answered, “I might as well come up there. Amanda and George have been through a lot already. Let’s give them a little more of a breather.”
“Fine, thanks, that’s very good of you,” Brenda said, the relief in her voice was obvious.
The following week Tony Hope-Jackson was sitting in the paneled conference room in the office of Robert Wynant, Attorney General of New York State. Brenda Richards and several other of Wynant’s staff were in attendance as well as the U. S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York and representatives of the FBI, SEC and a few others Tony didn’t remember. The issue, or rather THE ISSUE, was the fact that Tony’s masquerade as Amanda Littleton was about to be made public. Apparently someone on the defense team had been putting two and two together and Bob Wynant wanted to go before the Judge in the case with this potentially explosive piece of information before the defense started blanketing the media with their version of the story.
Tony was doing his best to keep it all together. What no one else in the room knew, what only Tony and his therapist knew, was that the masquerade had brought something to light that Tony had been unaware of before all of this had begun. He had been wrestling with it for months, accepting it, denying it, avoiding it, embracing it. The “it” was that those thirteen months Tony had spent as Amanda had profoundly changed him. The prospect of it was both exciting and terrifying. This was most definitely something that Tony had not bargained for. For the time being, at least, Tony thought that it would be a good idea to keep it under wraps.
Wynant and his team, with the possible exception of Brenda Richards, were so totally focused on getting Beau Chadsworth that Tony had become to them something of an afterthought. Oh yes, he would be their star witness, but his emotional state, or the impact that the masquerade had were not their concern. Throughout the two hour meeting Tony sat there trying to keep his feelings in check. They broke for a few minutes late in the second hour so that Bob Wynant could take an important call. Nearly everyone else reached for their cell phones, each person madly dialing their offices, all except Brenda Richards. She made a beeline for Tony. She linked his arm in hers and steered him into a side office. She didn’t close the door, that would have aroused suspicion. She sat on the edge of the unused desk and looked steadily at Tony.
“Tony — Amanda, honey,” she was no longer a high powered attorney, she easily slid into the role of a friend, “what’s the matter? You haven’t said a thing for the last hour and I can tell that you’re in turmoil.” Tony started to blurt out something when she held up her hand. “Sweetie, there’s nothing you have to prove to me; remember it’s me, Brenda.”
Tony looked at her for several silent moments; it may have been a year, it may have been thirty seconds, it didn’t matter. He didn’t say anything; he just began to cry silently. Tony’s back was to the door to the conference room and Brenda could see that noone was looking their way. She took Tony in her arms and held him gently. He felt incredibly safe being held that way. There was nothing but a few quiet tears; perhaps none of the rest of the people even noticed them. In fact there really wasn’t very much to see. Brenda knew, however, that it wasn’t simply the tension, the inevitable tension that Tony had been under that sparked even this little demonstration. Her sixth sense told her that this was something else. She thought that she knew, but she knew better than to offer her opinion.
“Brenda,” Tony began, his voice barely above a whisper, “something’s happened and I can’t explain it.” Brenda waited. “When Bob Wynant suggested that I pretend to be Amanda, I agreed because I was so angry at Beau that I would do whatever it took to expose his crime. Even when we were in Tuscany and I was learning to imitate Amanda, I was so intent on making it all work that I didn’t notice what was happening. Sometime around Christmas of last year, as I was shuttling between McLean and New York it began to dawn on me. It was like a bolt from the blue. It totally floored me. I didn’t know what to make of it; I still don’t. You know, the fact is that I was loving being Amanda. I liked her life, the work was interesting, George has been amazing through all this, I just adore him, the friendship that you and I have, that we still have, these and a hundred other things. Not only do I like these things, but there’s something else, they feel, oh, I don’t know...they feel right. Since all this began to unravel I’ve been seeing a therapist and she and I have been looking at all this and, well, ... oh, Brenda, I’m so confused.” His voice trailed off and the tears began again.
Brenda studied the face of the person she knew so well. Memories flashed before her of the many hours they had spent together. Under the “Amanda” costume, she had known there was a man, but she had noticed the change herself. When she first was getting to know Amanda, after that trip from Reagan National to McLean, the person she saw was woman enough, but perhaps something of an tomboy — a bit rough around the edges. She had known quite a few women like that. In many cases the slightly coarser gestures, the directness and the lack of guile of any sort were not so out of the ordinary. Over the next several months, however, it was as if the rough spots were all being polished away. The final “Amanda” wasn’t prissy or anything as obvious as that, rather she was more comfortable with herself. Somewhere along the way Brenda had realized that Amanda was simply a woman. The matter of the elaborate masquerade was something she didn’t think about, perhaps because there was nothing to remind herself of it.
She and Amanda had not seen all that much of each other. Amanda’s working in New York limited their contacts to the weekends. When they did get together to shop or have lunch at some little bistro, they easily relaxed into an ever deepening relationship. For her part, Amanda — the now ‘disappearing’ Tony — had never had a friendship like the one she had with Amanda. It wasn’t that they discussed every minute detail of each other’s lives or dissected every tiny alteration in each other’s emotional life, but it was the knowledge that they could if they needed to. So much open-ness, a powerful kind of intimacy: powerful and yet not threatening at the same time. It was a heady wine and Amanda savored every drop of it. It was the power of their friendship that both challenged and supported Amanda; it did the same for Brenda, but she had known such friendships before. As wonderful as it was, a friendship like this was what she had come to expect. Amanda was stunned by the novelty of it.
All of this was running through both of their minds as they stood in the outer office of Bob Wynant’s conference room.
“Brenda, Amanda is back with George; she’s got her life back, but I don’t want to go back to the life I led before. I want to go forward, yes, but I don’t want to stop being a woman. It means too much to me. I don’t think I can let it go. Do you think I’m crazy? Do you think I’m losing my mind?”
Brenda reached up and ran her fingers through Tony’s hair, smoothing back an imaginary curl. She smiled her gentlest smile, searching his face for clues as to what she might say. “No, darling, you are not losing your mind. You are not crazy. It sounds like the most logical thing in the world for you to want to be a woman.” She paused for a moment, her breath was taken away as she realized just how vulnerable Tony was just then. “Over the last several months I totally forgot that you had ever been a man. You were my friend Amanda, a woman in every way. I related to you as I related to any other woman. Oh, yes, I was very conscious of the job that I had to do as an attorney. But I didn’t think that I was an attorney for ‘a man in a dress.’ I could never have gotten as close to you as I did if you had been a man. Even with some of the wonderful men I know, at that level of intimacy they tend to close up. The fact is that you never did. But I wasn’t coming on to you and you weren’t coming on to me. It wasn’t like that.”
She took one of Tony’s hands in both of hers and held it silently for a moment before she continued. “I can only imagine that being Amanda for all these months has opened up something in you that has always been there. It’s a wonderful depth in you. Women know this depth. They see it in each other, not always, but they come to expect it in another woman. Frankly, women know that men are not like that. It’s not their fault; it’s just the way they are. You aren’t like those men. That wonderful depth in you is what makes you so special.” She lowered her voice; now it was her turn to whisper. “It’s what makes you a woman.” She paused again to see Tony’s reaction.
He looked at her for a long minute, gathering his thoughts. Brenda thought he was going to speak and then thought the better of it. All this while he let Brenda hold his hand in hers. It was as if he was taking his strength from her. At any moment Brenda half expected him to stiffen and withdraw his hand from hers, but he didn’t. Finally Tony spoke. His voice was soft and came from a place deep inside. It was the voice one might use in the confessional or with one’s most trusted confidant. She knew that at this time in their lives she was such for Tony. What their relationship would be in six months or a year no one could tell, but that was not the point. What was important was this very moment.
Now it was Tony’s turn to study his friend’s face. “Brenda,” he said “after all this is over, the trial, the publicity, the whole thing, I’m going to have to put my life together. It’s not going to be Wall Street and the high stakes poker of places like Harkness. I hope that I’ll be able to fade into the woodwork somewhere and live my life. Hearing you say that at some level I am a woman makes me feel good, really good. I’m happy about it and terrified at the same time. Exactly what I am going to do and how I’m going to do it are great big unknowns for me; I’ll deal with them as they come. I’ve got to get over some huge hurdles right now. There’s no doubt that the media will have a field day with ‘the cross-dressing spy’ at Harkness. And I know that Beau would like to crucify me if he could. I’m going to try to keep as low a profile as possible and take my direction from Bob Wynant. But after this is all over, I’ve got to pick up the pieces and I hope that we can be friends.”
Tony looked expectantly at Brenda. If her gaze at him could have softened any more than it was already, she would have let it. The tears of love and gratitude shining in her eyes told Tony everything he needed to know. There was one more hug before they returned to the conference room and the conclusion of the meeting. It would not have been appropriate for the two of them to hold hands for the rest of the meeting, but each of them, for their individual reasons, felt like doing so.
A subtle smile played over his features, but it was the relaxation of his shoulders as the weight of the tension he had been feeling began to lift that told Brenda what she needed to know. “I needed to tell you, Brenda. I know that you are my best friend, but I couldn’t help being worried what you would think of me. I know that the defense and the media will have a field day with my being Amanda for all those months; I was expecting that, but I was terrified that you might hate me for what I was feeling.”
Impulsively, Attorney General’s office or not, Brenda and Tony embraced for a moment.
Chapter V
Unless you have been subjected to it, it’s hard to imagine the glare of publicity that surrounds a high-profile that took place in Manhattan that Fall. Day after day the defense team filled the nightly news and the Sunday talk shows with their version of events. Rarely did Beau Chadsworth’s attorneys pass up the opportunity to vilify Tony Hope-Jackson a.k.a. Amanda Littleton. Every reference to Tony was tinged with characterizations that bordered on the libelous. Even when the Judge imposed her gag order on the defense and prosecution, these attorneys or their surrogates were out there day after day. The nightly comedy monologues and the comedy news shows all made reference to Tony aka Amanda.
Throughout it all Tony Hope-Jackson gave no interviews, made no statements, responded to no shouted questions. Amanda and George were similarly mute. It took the better part of a year before the reporters and camera people began to lose interest. So many cameras had been outside Tony’s Arlington, Virginia apartment and Amanda and George’s front door that television viewers counted the two residences as among the most recognized in America.
The trial took an inordinate amount of time. In fact the pundits were predicting that after all the pre-trail maneuvering the trial itself might seem anti-climactic. Teams of consultants had been brought in by both sides to prepare every facet. The millions of state and federal dollars spent on the trial passed new records. Throughout it all Chadsworth and his accomplices maintained their innocence. His courtroom performance endeared Chadsworth to some, but infuriated others. In the end the convictions were still stunning. The judge meted out sentences that would leave Chadsworth in a minimum security prison for nearly a quarter of a century; his accomplices fared no better. The monumental fines imposed were earmarked for a fund to compensate employees and investors who had borne the brunt of the monumental swindle Chadsworth and perpetrated.
The inevitable appeals followed, but the most amazing thing was that there was little gloating. Corporate and Financial America had awoken to a new, far chillier day. Even as some in the business world attempted to separate themselves from the excesses of Harkness, it was clear that investors had had enough. The markets slumped into a six-month’s period of “correction.” The high flyers had their wings clipped. They didn’t like it, but their was little sympathy for them. It came to be known as the Chadsworth effect. This would fascinate economists for years to come, but Tony Hope-Jackson couldn’t have cared less.
Anthony Hope-Jackson had other things to contemplate. Life had opened up in ways never imagined. That conversation with Brenda in that New York conference room had been the first quasi-public admission that the changes were deep and anything but trivial. As important as they were, however, Tony knew that the glare of publicity would follow him or her, as Tony began to think of herself. The Harkness business had to settle down completely before he thought that he would be able to stand the publicity.
What Antonia, as she now called herself, did surprised many people. Before doing it, however, she’d gone over it several times with her psychiatrist and with a publicity person her attorney had recommended. The step was unorthodox to say the least, but Antonia had been through a lot and she decided that the best way to handle her transition to living her life as a woman was to go public in a big way. The weekend before the Announcement, as she would think of it afterwards, she spoke with her mother and several close relatives, including Amanda and George Littleton. The following Monday she flew to New York.
She appeared on a comedy news program “It’s to Laugh,” on one of the slightly off-the-wall cable channels. Its host, David Litchfield, was known for his sardonic tongue in cheek approach to news stories. Litchfield attracted an audience that had more or less given up on television news. Appearing on his show was a bold move. Equally bold were her appearances on the two main late night talk shows the following nights. The hosts, led by Litchfield, were one minute serious, and laughing behind their hands the next. Antonia took them in stride. By the end of the interviews, the hosts had all showed their admiration for her courage not only in taking on the challenge of Beau Chadsworth, but of making the change to live her life publically as a woman. As nervous as she felt, she thought this approach would show that she was not ashamed of who she was and was no longer interested in hiding behind a cloak of anonymity. As her attorney had pointed out, prying reporters were determined to “out” her; it was only a matter of time. This way she beat them to the punch.
It wasn’t all a bed of roses, however. The tabloids still made up outrageous stories about her; linking her to one celebrity or another. The fact that she opened a free legal clinic for her “trans sisters,” as she called them, including sex workers, in one of the seedier sections of Los Angeles, only served to fuel their prurient imaginations. It became something of a joke when in a supermarket tabloid splashed a story on its cover identifying her only as “Toni H-J.” It made her laugh.
Her status as a minor celebrity as further enhanced by a character in one of the on-going television police dramas. Commentators noted that this was the first transsexual character on series television.
Antonia Hope-Jackson did go ahead and have her surgery, of course. And thanks to her some other transsexuals began to feel that if she could make the transition and survive and continue to contribute to society, then they could too. Of all the things that she had done, Toni was most proud of this accomplishment.
The End
I would like to thank Angela Rasch and Randalynn for their editorial help; the story is much better thanks to them. Any remaining faults and mistakes are my own.
Synopsis: One holiday season, a desperate store executive, an earnest young man with a dream even he couldn’t put into words, a secretly lonely young woman who needed a good friend and didn’t know it; they all came together and a special something, or someone was added to the mix. The result: maybe a little magic, the kind that lasts.
The Unexpected Elf.
Jim Torrance was getting very worried. Everything had seemed to be perfectly in place for Williams Town Center Mall’s Christmas display at the big box store, Jefford’s. Santa, of course, as the centerpiece with a North Pole village, reindeer, candy canes, everything in place and only two hours to go before it opened. What worried him was that one of the elves had quit. To a casual observer that might not seem to be much of a problem, but then that observer didn’t understand the intricacies of Holiday marketing.
That day’s copy of the Wall Street Journal was on his desk and the article about the weakness in the retail markets and the indicies of Consumer Confidence didn’t bode well. You see, to say that Jim Torrance was overextended was an understatement. Jim was the head of Jefford’s Stores operations here in Williamsville and his yearly bonus, deferred compensation, hell, his very job depended on meeting the analysts’ projections for yearly sales. He knew he was perilously close to not meeting those projections unless holiday sales beat or at least met analysts’ expectations. One little thing could upset his plans, could send him home with a pink slip, or if he was lucky, just a humiliating demotion. He didn’t need an elf to quit just two hours before Jefford’s opened on Black Friday, the day after Thanksgiving.
It wouldn’t have been so bad if he’d had someone to replace that elf. She was one of two attractive young women whose job it was to stand at the entrance to the Santa display and tell kids and their parents, “Oh, Santa really would like to talk to you. Santa does want to know what you’d like for Christmas. Here give me your hand and I’ll introduce you to Santa.” That’s the gist of what the elf would say to the kids. To the parents or grandparents, the elf would indicate which department sold those toys the little ones so greatly desired. It may not have been apparent to the customers, but those elves were crucial to the whole carefully calibrated Santa operation. Jim’s problem was that the job of the elf was complicated enough that he couldn’t just call a Temp agency and say, “Got any spare elves?”
Jim’s desperation gave him the impetus to reach for anything that might help him solve this problem. He brought in Joyce Berger, the head of HR at Jefford’s, and together they thought of any employee who might fill the bill. Nothing. Everybody was too busy, too — shall we say — generously proportioned, too old, too reticent around children. It was nearly eight a.m. Jefford’s would open at nine. What to do? What to do? The two executives sat in stony silence. The air was thick with tension.
At that moment Jim Torrance’s nephew Bob Richards was arriving at work at Jeffords. I think you know Bob, or somebody like him. Medium, height, medium build — maybe a little thin, actually — medium brown hair, hazel eyes. The quintessential nice guy. Fresh out of college with a business degree. The job in the credit department was for Bob a stepping stone to nowhere. He took it seriously, though. He tended to take everything seriously. Conscientious was his middle name. There was one thing about him, that few people knew. He loved children and dreamt of the day he would be a parent. He’d even volunteered in a daycare center when he was in college. When other people talked about fulfilling their community service requirements by helping homeless people or working in a blood drive, Bob Richards’s dream was to help take care of little ones. Oh, yes, he got a few stares. Even in the 21st Century this was still women’s work. And he was scrupulously conscious of any childhood molestation issues. He’d always kept on the weather side of that fine line between genuine love for children and something else he didn’t like to contemplate.
I suppose in later years people might wonder at the confluence of the fates that brought Bob Richards out of the credit department and his uncle, Jim Torrance out of his office at precisely the same moment. Or maybe people would ponder the backward glance that Torrance gave his nephew as he hastened to fulfill whatever clerk’s task that took him over to Finance, but it really wouldn’t matter. Suffice it to say that Jim Torrance’s desperation tipped the balance. He suddenly realized that Bob Richards, his otherwise nondescript nephew had the precise physique for a Christmas elf. “Oh, Bob,” he called after the two had exchanged the usual morning pleasantries, “could I talk to you for a minute?”
Bob Richards knew that whatever he had to do it wasn’t as important as obeying the summons from Jefford’s regional vice-president even if he was his uncle. There wasn’t an avuncular arm around the shoulder, nor any forced bonhomie in Torrance’s request of his nephew. It was an order plain and simple.
“Bob, I know that you’ve wanted to see the retail operation up close. Well, an opportunity has opened up that I’d like you to fill for us. It’s in the Christmas display area. Go right down to Joyce Berger in HR and she’ll explain it all to you. We’re all counting on you, Bob.”
If Bob Richards heard the desperation in his uncle’s tone of voice, he didn’t say anything about it. He hoped that maybe, just maybe, this would be his chance to show the powers that be just how valuable he could be to Jefford’s. Little did he know.
Joyce Berger’s office was smaller than his uncle’s office, but sill quite a bit larger than his cubicle. Without intending to, Bob took mental note of it and secretly wondered if an office like this might be his one day.
“I’ll get right to the point,” Joyce began. Any reservations she had about what she was about to ask this young man to do she kept to herself. She knew better than to question Mr. Torrance when he issued a directive. Maybe, the forty-ish woman, whose clothes sense tended more to the severe than the stylish, thought to herself 'this might actually work.' “Bob, we need you to work for the rest of the holiday season in the Santa’s village area. You’ll be one of the elves. Betty O’Donnell quit this morning and we need someone there right away. Mr. Torrance wants you to help us out and my job is to give you all the support you need. The costume and everything you’ll need is right here in this box.”
“Of course, I’ll be only to glad to help, but aren’t the elves women?” Bob was trying to think of a graceful way to bow out though he truly wanted to be helpful, but never, in his wildest dreams, had he ever thought that it would come to dressing like a woman.
“Bob, yes they are, but we don’t have anybody in the store, any woman that is, who could fill in and there’s not enough time to train somebody from the outside. Outside of the retail staff nobody knows the store as well as you. It’ll be a breeze. Carol Jenkins will be the other elf and will be there with you every step of the way.” Joyce had seen Bob Richards looking longingly at Carol and suspected that he secretly carried the torch for Carol, the store’s new sales associate. No wonder: Carol, a fresh faced brunette of twenty three, had caught the eye of half the men in the store. “Besides, the costume’s pretty unisex anyway. Just think of Will Ferrel in the “Elf” movie a couple of Christmases ago.” With a gesture that he knew better than to question, Joyce ushered him out of her office.
Almost not believing it himself, he found his way to the employee’s locker room and found Carol, alias Cheery the Elf, waiting for him. Carol had determined to give Jefford's and Williamsville one more chance. She'd followed a former boyfriend here and now it all was nothing more than a sea of unhappy memories for her. Her voice was flat and her welcome no more than perfunctory.
“Morning, Bob, the tights and the leotard may be a little new to you, but they should fit; you’re about the same size as Betty O’Donnell.” Bob nodded numbly. In the locker room he found the leotard and the tights, green leather shorts, the pointy-toed soft leather boots, the little vest and the hat.
After a moment, from his side of the door he called out to Carol, “Um, what am I supposed to wear under this stuff?”
Carol thought quickly. “Stay there a minute, I’ll be right back.” A few moments later she reappeared with a packet of panties and a sports bra. “Put these on first and, um, tuck, um, yourself in. Then put the tights and the leotard on over them, then let me see.”
Bob wasn’t sure how many shades of red he turned at these instructions. He thanked God for the fact that he was in the locker room and she was outside. His ‘fight or flight’ reflex was working overtime, but he could see no alternative. When he’d managed to get all the bits and pieces of the costume on, there was only fifteen minutes to spare before opening. Timidly exiting his locker room refuge, Carol gave him the once over. Well, actually she gave him quite a thorough going over.
“There, that’s pretty good. You only need a couple of finishing touches and you’ll be all set. She reached into her bag and produced a hairbrush and a tube of lipstick. With a few deft brush strokes she managed to make his hair seem less “mannish” as she put it. Putting on his elf’s hat she smiled momentarily. “Here, look up and me and purse your lips.” Before he could object his lips got a touch of color. At this point Bob was on psychological overload. This self-protecting daze enabled him to feel as if he were watching himself from a distance.
There was enough of the conscientious Bob still left functioning, however, to listen to Carol’s instructions about where to stand and what to say and, above all else, to smile. The doors opened at the stroke of nine that last Friday of November, and Bob’s life was never the same again. If he had been nervous or the slightest bit apprehensive before his new job as a Christmas elf began, it all evaporated at the sight of the mothers and their little ones.
Somewhere, somehow, deeply buried in the psyche of Bob Richards was a Christmas elf just waiting to break free. It isn’t often true even when people say that somebody “was born to be” one thing or another. It really is just a figure of speech, isn’t it? In Bob’s case, however, it was true beyond his, or anyone else’s expectations. In the first few hours of that very first Friday, amidst the welter of avid shoppers and their small children, often frazzled beyond words, Bob Richards became the Christmas elf. Shy children, tired children, fretful children, even terrified children were calmed by Merry, the elf. For that is what Bob had become. She held their hands and, at first tentatively, then warmly returned their little hugs. Angry and recalcitrant eight and nine year olds, bored beyond words simply wanted to be near her. Oh yes, Santa was who the little ones came to see and to the jolly old man they revealed their deepest Christmas wishes, but it was Merry, the elf they remembered. There was something in her smile, warming, yes, and comforting, too, but somehow penetrating as well. Those bored older children shyly waited for their hugs, too. They didn’t know why they felt magnetized to her, but they were. Truth be told neither did Bob Richards.
Carol Jenkins, Merry’s partner Cheery the elf, felt it too. That warmth. Oh, yes, Carol had seen Bob around the office, had even caught a few of his furtive glances. She was beyond dubious about the idea of Bob taking the place of Betty O’Donnell; she was almost hostile. She and Betty had been a team. But Joyce had promised her that if she could endure working with Bob Richards, there would be a handsome bonus in it for her. But that first day, even in the very first hour Carol sensed something was different. She watched initially in amusement, later in awe as Bob became Merry the elf. The awkwardness had disappeared. Bob was gentle and even graceful with the children.
He smiled often at her and made a special point of deferring to her whenever he could. Between visits by the little ones, the two elves chatted when they could and Carol could feel herself drawn to Merry, the elf. Each time she looked over it was as if her eyes were deceiving her. Where there had been Bob Richards in an elf costume, suddenly it was no fellow employee filling in during a minor emergency, but a graceful woman who wore the elf costume as if it were the most gorgeous outfit in the world. What Carol didn’t know, what Bob certainly didn’t know was that there was more there than met the eye.
Oh I know, dear reader, that you are very far past that point when Santa and his elves were anything but a charming story. You’ve seen “It’s a Wonderful Life,” “Miracle on 34th Street,” and all the other Christmas movies. Perhaps you have children of your own and have watched the enchantment dance in their eyes on a Christmas morning when they believe that Santa Claus has come. “The Night Before Christmas” by Clement Moore might even have been a holiday favorite you’ve read as a special aunt or uncle. What you may not know, perhaps because in our frenetic world of the Internet and iPod’s and global warming we rarely have the opportunity to pause and think, is that there is something out there. Now, I know, that in most of us there is something of the skeptic or perhaps even the agnostic. To us therefore these charming stories are just that: charming stories. And that’s fine. As charming stories they fulfill an important function. But for those of us who have seen that first cloud of disillusionment darken the face of a six or seven year old when she realizes that maybe these are nothing more than charming stories, we know that something has been lost, something very precious.
But there is. Something. Someone, actually waiting and watching. And at this season of the year, even as the crass commercialism threatens to overwhelm us all, an awareness of that special something creeps into our consciousness. Perhaps it does so to remind us that as cold and cruel as the world is sometimes, we are not alone. Let’s leave it there, dear reader. You go ahead and put a name to it. Maybe the religious trappings that some people put on that sensibility make you uncomfortable. No matter. Making you uncomfortable is not my purpose here. I am only a story teller telling you about what happened that recent Christmas season a year or so ago. For my part I’ll put a name to it, but that’s just me. If it makes you uncomfortable, I’m sorry, just forget about it and skip ahead. Just imagine that the thing I’m going to recount is no more than a shared feeling that the closeness of the Holidays brings out an awareness of just how special each one of us is and how we ought to find ways to be kinder to each other.
That being said, for me at least, some very special ones were keeping a careful eye on Bob Richards. These were the ones — oh, let’s just call them elves and be done with it — who transformed him into Merry the elf. Along the way they found something in Bob that he didn’t know was there. They found out, they knew all along, actually, that Bob was a woman, that it was his destiny to become a woman. And all of this that began to happen that Thanksgiving Friday at Jefford’s in the Williams Town Center Mall was their way of helping him along. What Carol Jenkins saw as she watched Bob become Merry the elf was the beginning of that transformation that would make that whole person emerge as she was meant to be. Of course, Carol didn’t know that as it began. Neither did the adoring children or their hugely relieved mothers.
Carol did have a clue, though when the second or third apologetic mother looked with pleading eyes at Merry and practically begged her to let her child stay at Santa’s village with Merry while she tried frantically to complete the rest of her shopping. These mothers knew even before they’d finished asking that Merry would say yes. There was something that Carol saw in Merry’s face: a kind of a glow, or something, she wasn’t quite sure. It was undoubtedly a woman’s look of deep, unspoken sympathy. It was something she caught out of the corner of her eye. You see, Carol was a pretty down to earth sort of person. Although she had a good sense of humor, she wasn’t usually the first person who got the joke. Therefore what was happening right before her eyes just didn’t comport with the rest of her matter of fact life.
Sometime after lunch, Jim Torrance came by Santa’s village. He couldn’t get too close because there were too many people. The crowd of children was pretty well behaved, too. Torrance had come to the area from his office and so he didn’t immediately see where the elves were standing. That meant that he didn’t realize what the source of interest was. What he did see was that there was an unusually large number of shoppers crowding each cash register station. That made him breathe just that little bit easier. But he didn’t yet connect it with the activity taking place at Santa’s village. He returned to his office to a stack of message slips his secretary had left for him. He recognized a few callers’ names, and he expected that there would be the usual smattering of complaints forwarded to him that couldn’t be handled by subordinates.
He began to return the calls and was surprised to hear compliment after compliment. “I just had to call, Mr. Torrance,” one woman began, “the new elf in Santa’s village — I think her name is Mary or something like that — made my two-year-old’s day. He couldn’t stop talking about her. I want you to know I’ll be doing all my shopping at Jefford’s this year.” Those comments were music to his ears. He sat back in his chair. He still didn’t connect the dots. That wouldn’t happen for a few more days yet.
Back at Santa’s village it was nearing closing time. The river of children and their parents had slowed to a trickle. Although the day had been long, the elation that Carol felt made her less conscious of her aching feet. But Bob Richards had been enjoying the most wonderful day of his life. How many children had come his way he couldn’t say. Each one of them was precious to him. What he didn’t realize was that each of those children felt the same way about Merry the elf. She was extraordinary.
The doors were finally shut and the lights were dimmed. Carol and Merry began to make their way back to the employees’ locker room. “That was quite a day,” Carol began. Merry could only shake her head in disbelief. Without thinking Carol took Merry’s hand. It seemed so natural. She would never have thought so with Bob Richards. Merry responded with a radiant smile that told Carol everything she needed to know. In the space of a single day a special bond had been forged between the two. It would be something that Carol would reflect on. She’d never had a friendship like this before.
The person who had become Merry the elf that day was in a state that was beyond elation. It was more than the fulfillment of Bob Richards’s wildest dreams. He felt more alive than at any time he could ever remember. But now there was something else. He couldn’t put his finger on it, but it was definitely there. That night, back in his little apartment he slept like a baby. His dreams were vivid and comforting. Whatever was happening was very good, that much Bob knew. Instead of a large coffee from the corner shop on the way into work the next morning, a mug of fragrant scented tea seemed more in order. Even on that second day he didn’t notice the looks that his graceful, almost balletic movements caused among the other customers. Well, he might have noticed, but it really didn’t concern him. What he did notice were the women around him. Whereas before his adventure as Merry the elf his looks were of longing for that which would never be his, now his looks were admiring, but of women’s clothes, their hair, their makeup. The women in the coffee shop sensed that his looks were anything but threatening. Returning his bright smiles made them feel somehow giddy.
In its own subtle way it was even more pronounced at Jefford’s. Carol greeted her colleague with a warm hug. She hadn’t realized until she saw Merry the elf emerge from the locker room just how much she was looking forward to working with her. If there had been a casual observer there, she might have been forgiven for mistaking the two elves for sisters, so close had they become.
The day flew by and although, if anything, it was busier than the day before, it went smoothly. And that was the pattern. Word had begun to spread in Williamsville about Merry the elf at Jefford’s. Both elves soon recognized many children and their parents returning for a second or even a third visit. Where mothers had brought their children, now it was the father’s turn. Oh, yes, there were the obligatory pictures with the child on Santa’s lap, but as many wanted their picture with Merry the elf, as well. The children’s radiant smiles were reflections of hers. Jim Torrance was thrilled. The day sheets told the tale. This was going to be the best holiday season in the store’s history. There were smiles all around. So small an impression had the old Bob Richards made on his uncle, however, that Torrance didn’t even remember that Bob had taken on the role of Merry the elf. That meant, of course, that for several days he didn’t connect the success with his relative’s efforts.
It was his HR chief, Joyce Berger who called his attention to it. “Mr. Torrance, everybody’s been talking about the new elf. Bob Richards has been doing a phenomenal job.”
“No. Yes, That’s right. Omigod, I forgot the kid’s in the elf costume. My nephew the crossdresser, hah!” Mr. Torrance was not noted for his progressive views on such matters.
Joyce felt honor bound to set him straight. “Well, Mr. Torrance, sir, it’s not exactly like that. You really need to take another look.” Her words seemed to get his attention. “O.k., I’ll go over there after my ten o’clock.”
Even he had to wait until he could get close enough to see the elves in action, so great had the crowd become. Torrance saw his chief of security, his face wreathed in smiles.
“Jack, is it always like this?” Torrance was incredulous.
“Every day, sir.” Jack answered with pride in his voice. “She’s a magnet for all the kids...and their parents,” he added for emphasis.
Before he could get any closer, Torrance noticed that the register stations seemed almost as crowded. Finally he got close enough to see. Both elves, smiling broadly were talking to the children and one of them had two or three toddlers clinging to her legs. She didn’t seem to mind, though. Torrance noticed the other elf assisting her and the two of them deftly guiding their little charges towards Santa’s sleigh. He could tell that something special was going on; he just wasn’t sure what it was. He only knew it was good. And then Merry the elf, with the little ones clinging to her looked in Torrance’s direction. Her smile of recognition was so genuine and brilliant that Torrance felt warmed and gratified by it.
Torrance was pleased, but there was something else. He didn’t notice it right then, but no matter. Somehow or other it had registered with him. You might have said it was that special glow, but there again words are just too clumsy to convey something so subtle, so evanescent as that. The seed had been planted. And it would grow. Just not all at once.
Carol Jenkins began noticing things, a few little things, as early as the first week of December. She’d seen Bob Richards’s I. D. picture once or twice before hanging on its Jefford’s ribbon around Bob’s neck. It was typically unflattering. One early morning the two were chatting before the store opened and she happened to glance at the picture. It was definitely changed; she couldn’t say how. If she didn’t know any better she thought it looked like a woman in men’s clothing. She looked again at Bob and noticed a softer, rounder outline to his features. She glanced again at the picture and it was certainly Bob, but it somehow was a more feminine Bob. He noticed her perplexed look and asked her if anything was wrong. Carol was flustered for a minute, but passed it off as nothing. Carol, however, didn’t forget it.
Later on an odd thought occurred to her. In a quieter moment she looked at Merry and found herself thinking how flattering that little vest looked on her. Flattering, but as a woman’s clothes are flattering. Then there was the time Carol was talking to a mother and saw Merry leaning down to put a toddler back into her stroller. Merry definitely had an unmistakably female figure that Carol knew she had never seen before. Merry may not have been a raving beauty, but there was nothing of the man about her. Another time Merry cradled a six month old against her and to Carol the angle that the baby was resting indicated that there was more to Merry’s chest than there had been before. Merry’s hips were wider, too.
Then the time that the two were changing at the end of the day. Carol noticed Merry take off her cap and shake out her hair. It was a fleeting gesture, but only one that a person would use who had a lifetime of long hair. Bob Richards’s hair had never been long and even Merry’s hair was only long enough to be pixie-ish. What struck Carol was that the gesture was natural and unstudied. But Carol was a logical person. She didn’t believe in magical transformations. There must be another reason, there had to be. What surprised Carol the most were her own reactions to the changes. Her brain may have been telling her that such things were impossible. Her heart told her that they were perfectly natural.
So passed that magical Christmas season just a year or so ago. By the twenty-fourth of December, the picture on the I. D. was that of a woman completely. The name was changed, too. It no longer read Bob Richards, but Meredith Richards, and everybody called her...Merry. There were other changes, too. A group of teenagers from Williamsville District High School (who’d spent more time being Mall flowers than anything else) began volunteering every afternoon after school. They were the Merry helpers as they called themselves. They were even joined by some of the skateboarders in the parking lot out back; these gangly boys were Merry helpters, too. The kids from The Hill School, a center for children with various development challenges the next town over, came on a field trip one day, each with an accompanying adult. It was supposed to be one day, but they came back every day for the next two weeks.
Mr. Torrance and his family, Merry Richards and her parents hosted a Christmas dinner for all the single store employees not spending the holiday with their families. The post-Christmas sales at Jefford’s put the finishing touch on the year for the scores of happy shoppers, the employees who, unexpectedly were thanked profusely by customers and management alike. Oh yes, and Mr. Torrance the sales figures justified his bonus and saved his job.
In the new year Merry was offered a job at the Hill School where she was welcomed by everyone and began taking courses for a degree in special education. Within a year Jefford’s was closed in a consolidation move with several department store chains. Suddenly finding himself at loose ends, Mr. Torrance was asked to serve on the board of the county hospital; he saw no reason not to. His wife was quietly relieved since he’d turned down all their offers in the past. Carol Jenkins met Jerry Martin and their whirlwind courtship ended in a wedding the following May. Merry was her maid of honor, of course. Carol and she had become like the sisters neither one had.
I would like to tell you that Merry Richards was soon married and eagerly anticipating the joys of motherhood herself, but that’s not the way things worked out, sadly. I don’t think that anybody really understood what was in the mind of that distraught man, Charles Anthony, a father of a former Hill School student. Nor was it clear why he singled Merry out. Perhaps no one will ever know. If we did it might make what I’m about to tell you a little easier, easier for you and easier for me to tell. You see, Merry had stopped in at the Hill School that hot July Saturday afternoon. She loved the school and spent many of her free hours there completing one project or another. She was alone in her classroom. The people at the school were not even sure that she had even met Charles Anthony. But she was there, at the wrong place at the wrong time when Charles burst into her classroom. There’s no record of their conversation; the neighbors only remember hearing him shouting something, a gunshot, seeing him on the steps of the school, another shot and it was all over.
The outpouring of grief over the loss of Merry was like nothing Williamsville had ever seen. The people who spoke at her memorial service began to notice something, however, as they spoke. As they reminisced a calm almost a peace began to be felt. Their grief was very real, but somehow the spirit of Merry Richards was there in the little church overflowing with townsfolk. Amongst the tears there were the beginnings of smiles and even some gentle laughter. People consoled one another with a kind word or a remembrance of Merry and their feelings of comfort spread through the crowd. It encompassed the Anthony family as well. That poor family felt it too, in their double grief. Thoughts and prayers for Charles Anthony began to be heard as well.
The place where Merry's family buried her was just a couple of states over, the little town where she had grown up. The horticulturalist from the state university was asked to explain the phenomenon. It had something to do with micro-climates and the like. I confess I didn't understand the explanation even after I had read it a couple of times. Suffice it to say that at her grave snow melts quickly, the grass stays green and flowers bloom twelve months of the year.
The next year The Hill School was renamed The Merry Richards Hill School by unanimous consent of their Board. The Williamsville District High School group, the Merry helpers, decided on their own to volunteer there and naturally they kept the name Merry helpers for that's what they were. Jim Torrance had taken the job of the school’s unpaid executive director. He did the occasional odd consulting job for the County government to keep food on his family’s table. The idea of making lots of money no longer interested him. A picture of Merry the elf was framed on his desk.
There was something else about Jim. He’d seen an ad for a hot line for transgendered youth in the local paper. Not really understanding why he took the training and worked there every Thursday. He became known for his sympathetic, non-judgemental approach; so much so that trans teens, even those who weren’t in crisis made it a habit to call on Thursdays because they knew that a particularly sympathetic adult would always listen.
One night one of the kids was a little confrontational, “Hey Jim,” she challenged, “are you a tranny, too?”
He chuckled at that. “No, no, I’m not, but thanks for asking.”
“Well, then why are you here talking to us?”
Without thinking Jim blurted out, “An elf made me do it.”
“Merry?” the teen asked.
At the sound of her name, for the first time in twelve years since his father died, Jim Torrance burst into tears. The teen and the other kids were all very solicitous, but Jim said, “It’s o.k. Every once in a while you have to let it out. Merry would understand.” Even the kids who had only heard about Merry the elf agreed. It didn’t change any of the complexities of their lives, but Jim and the kids all felt a little closer to one another after that.
The following spring Carol and Jerry’s twins were born: a girl and a boy. They named their son Bob and nobody was surprised when they named their daughter Merry. They all understood the name Merry; they didn't know about Bob. But Carol did. She remembered Bob Richards; only a very few people did. Naturally she told her husband Jerry. She remembered a brave young man, whom most people underestimated, who risked ridicule and God knows what else to help without any thought to how it might benefit him. Carol hoped that her children might grow up to be as brave as that. He had exemplified the idea of stepping up to the plate. She thought it would be good to remember that kind of selfless generosity.
In a couple of years it was Carol’s turn to stand with the twins at another Santa’s village in a different store in a different town. It was a struggle for Carol not to be overwhelmed by her memories. The twins were a great distraction and she held them just that little bit closer. ‘Help me, Merry,’ she prayed silently. It was when she was standing there that something strange happened. As she looked around, she sensed it, felt it rather than saw it. It was a presence. It was so strong that she looked around much as a person does who feels that someone is looking at her. But there was no one looking at her, except of course the children.
Then Carol realized what it was. The looks on those expectant children’s faces had something special about them. She knew what it was. It was that wonderful, unmistakable glow, the smile of Merry the elf.
It made her smile, too.
Epilogue
Well, it was my job as the editor of the Williamsville Herald Examiner to put Merry's story to paper. I hope you don't mind. There's one thing more, though. It started the next Christmas. People around these parts began to look one another in the eye and put just a little bit more emphasis on the word "Merry," as they wished "Merry Christmas." I guess it was their way of trying to bring something of Merry's own special joy into their holiday wishes. The idea quickly spread and now we all do it because we all understand what it means. And now I guess you know Merry's story, too, so let me wish you all from the bottom of my heart, "A very Merry Christmas."
The End.